Should Fox Cancel American Idol?
The ratings for American Idol were way down this season, about 32 percent lower than those of season 10.
The winners on American Idol all appear to be from the same mold, as Phillip Phillips follows in the Caucasian, guitar-playing footsteps of Lee DeWyze, Kris Allen, David Cook (pictured) and Scotty McCreery.
So, it must be asked: is it actually time to cancel American Idol?
Yes, Allen told TMZ this week. He believes the plug should be pulled on a competition that has clearly grown tiresome on the eyes of viewers.
But another former winner disagrees.
American Idol is a juggernaut," Taylor Hicks told TMZ in response to Allen. Because of my American Idol win, I am able to do the thing that I love most, which is to be an entertainer... the fact that I am headlining Vegas six years after auditioning there and then ultimately winning AI is testament to the incredible platform the show continues to provide for me."
What do YOU think? Should American Idol get the axe?
View Poll »
Phillip Phillips Loves Girlfriend, Embraces Talent
We're sorry to say it, ladies, but: Phillip Phillips has a girlfriend. And he's head over heels for the unnamed brunette.
"She is so excited for me," the 21-year old told reporters in a conference call yesterday. "She supported me throughout all of this, and I love her to death."
Phillip added that his gal pal has helped him immensely through his kidney ailment - it came out this week that Phillips underwent EIGHT surgeries during season 11 and is due for one in the near future - and if female voters out there have a problem with his heart being taken, well...
... too bad!
"If a girl [voted] for me because I'm cute, and then gets mad that I have a girlfriend, then she doesn't really like the music," he said. "I'm not some cute guy who is trying to be successful off that. I really want the music to come first."
So, why did YOU vote Phillip Phillips for American Idol winner?
View Poll »
Young Jessica Sanchez Fan CRUSHED By American Idol Results
We've found her! The only female on the planet who did not vote Phillip Phillips for American Idol champion!
Granted, she's like four years old.
It's both hilarious and heart-breaking to watch her reaction to this week's finale results. But it should at least be comforting to Fox executives - following a season where ratings tumbled - to know that at least some fans out there still care. A lot.
Watch poor little Laney's reaction to the outcome now and start the hate mail campaign for the mother behind the camera, who seems to take pleasure in mocking her toddler's pain:
Jessica Sanchez: Phillip Phillips Deserved to Win American Idol
Upon winning American Idol last night, Phillip Phillips dissolved into tears and hugged his parents. It was a beautiful, pure moment of happiness.
But, moments prior to that celebration, Jessica Sanchez treated viewers to a lovely moment herself: expressing true pride and satisfaction when her opponent's name was called.
"I really think that Phillip deserves to win and I'm so happy for him," Sanchez told reporters after all was said and done, adding of Phillip: "He has his funny side and his humble side and he's just an amazing, original artist."
The same is true for Sanchez, who may have lost, but who was involved in what most consider the best performance of the evening: a duet with Jennifer Holliday on "And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going." Watch, be amazed and wish this runner-up luck now:
SHOULD PHILLIP PHILLIPS HAVE WON AMERICAN IDOL?
View Poll »
Rihanna vs. Jennifer Lopez: Who Would You Rather...
Many questions can be raised about last night's American Idol finale. To wit:
Should Phillip Phillips have defeated Jessica Sanchez? Should Diana DeGarmo have accepted Ace Young's proposal? How incredible is Jennifer Holliday?!?
But THG is focused on the truly important issue of the night: With both Rihanna and J. Lo taking to the stage and performing a couple sexy, scantily-clad singles, the topic can no longer be ignored. Which of these beauties would you prefer to bang?
Study their finale outfits and vote now.
Phillip Phillips Reacts to American Idol Victory
He is the champion, our friends.
It took months of performing and over 132 million votes, but Phillip Phillips was finally crowned the American Idol winner last night. And while the outcome may have been clear to many fans for a long time now, try telling that to the 11th title-holder in show history.
"I don't really feel anything," Phillip told reporters after the show. "Its crazy I'm still a little numb from the whole situation, it's just so unreal. Did I think I was gonna win? Heck no. It's so unreal. It hasn't sunk in yet.
"It's such a blessing to have, I'm kinda ready to try and comprehend it all. After I won, I wasn't thinking about anything. I wasn't thinking about the song, I wasn't wanting to sing or anything. I just started thinking about the journey and how far all of us have come and how far we made it, it's so overwhelming. Jessica has a huge future ahead of her and we're both supportive of each other. I love playing music and I'm just a lucky guy."
Relive this singer's journey now in our Phillip Phillips video section and then vote: Did the right contestant win?
View Poll »
American Idol Results: Who Won?
Following a record 132 million votes, performances from Neil Diamond, Rihanna and Aerosmith and a proposal, American Idol crowned a season 11 champion tonight.
Was it ballad singer extraordinaire Jessica Sanchez? Or Dave Matthews prototype Phillip Phillips? Unlike Ryan Seacrest, we won't keep you in suspense for very long. The winner is...
PHILLIP PHILLIPS!
Not exactly a shocker, huh? The guitar-playing crooner was considered a favorite from his very first audition, considering his similar qualities to every other American Idol champion of the past five seasons.
Jessica appeared genuinely happy for Phillip upon hearing the announcement, as Ryan handed Phillip his guitar, Phillips took the crowd "Home" and eventually dissolved into tears, heading into the crowd to hug his parents.
Did Phillip Phillips deserve to win?
View Poll »
Ace Young Proposes to Diana DeGarmo on American Idol Finale!
Move over, Phillip Phillips and Jessica Sanchez. Ace Young just stole your spotlight.
About a half hour prior to American Idol announcing its season 11 champion tonight, Young and Diana DeGarmo - who met during a production of Hair - were called on to the stage by Ryan Seacrest.
Young then got down on one knee, and in a proposal/product placement for Dave Webb Jewelry, said to his live-in girlfriend:
"I want to make this last forever, and I will do anything in my power to have the most amazing life together, if you will have me."
Through tears, DeGarmo accepted!
“I’m so speechless right now,” she said after Young put the engagement ring on her finger. “My makeup’s running!”
Diane finished second on the third season of Idol in 2004, while Young placed seventh on season five. Congrats to the happy couple!
American Idol Finale: Who Won the Night?
One episode. Two finalists. Three songs.
Phillip Phillips squared off against Jessica Sanchez tonight, with the American Idol Season 11 crown at stake. Each contestant was tasked with singing a trio of tracks:
- Simon Fuller's selections: Jessica Sanchez, “I Have Nothing” by Whitney Houston; Phillip Phillips, “Stand By Me” by Ben E. King
- A favorite from earlier in the season: Jessica Sanchez in no heels, “The Prayer” by Celine Dion; Phillip Phillips, “Movin’ Out” by Billy Joel
- A potential winning single: Jessica Sanchez, “Change Nothing;" Phillip Phillips, “Home”
So, who deserves the crown? Watch all six performance videos below and then vote...
WHO SHOULD WIN?
View Poll »
Phillip Phillips vs. Jessica Sanchez: Who Will Win?
We're down to two on American Idol. The final two. Phillip Phillips and Jessica Sanchez.
One is a young white male who is easy on the eyes and plays the guitar. In other words: the same exact pedigree as the last four winners.
The other has a beautiful voice and hasn't been afraid all year long of tacking such major artists as Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey. She's responsible for the single most memorable American Idol performance of the season.
Either would be a worthy champion. Only one will wear the crown next Thursday night.
Who do you want it to be?
View Poll »
