Mindy McCready Death: Is Celebrity Rehab Exploitation to Blame?

by at .  Updated at . Comments

News of troubled country singer Mindy McCready's death from a self-inflicted gunshot wound took the celebrity news world by storm late Sunday.

Criticism of VH1's Celebrity Rehab spread almost as fast.

Mindy is now the fifth celebrity cast member to die since appearing on the show, hosted by Dr. Drew Pinsky, and the third from Season 3 alone.

Mindy McCready and Dr. Drew

The Celebrity Rehab stars who died before McCready:

  • Mike Starr, bassist for Alice in Chains
  • Joey Kovar, a Real World participant
  • Rodney King of L.A. riots fame
  • Actor Jeff Conaway

Starr and Kovar overdosed, King was found dead in his pool with alcohol and marijuana in his system, Conaway died of pneumonia and an infection.

All stirred up rumors of a curse and a debate about the show's purpose/helpfulness. Mindy's apparent suicide upped the pitch of the reaction, however.

Singer Richard Marx, who made news slamming Chris Brown earlier this month, compared Pinsky to Dr. Jack Kevorkian on Twitter: "Same results."

Marx backed off later, saying the crack went too far.

He reiterated, however, that the show is ... well ... "It is, however, my opinion that what Dr. D does is exploitation and his track record is not good," he wrote.

VH1's Celebrity Rehab with Dr. Drew is not currently on the air. Pinsky switched his focus to non-celebrities in Season 6 last fall and changed the title to Rehab.

Season 3, shot in 2009, featured McCready, Dennis Rodman, Tom Sizemore, Mackenzie Phillips, Heidi Fleiss and a handful of lesser known celebrities.

McCready was a sympathetic character on the show and appeared far less damaged than her fellow cast members in terms of full-fledged addiction.

Pinsky diagnosed her with "love addiction." Mindy suffered a seizure while on the show, further endearing her to Dr. Drew and the others.

In an interview with The Associated Press several months later, he said McCready had a good shot at recovery if she remained in treatment.

"Like with anybody I treat, it's really up to them," Pinsky said. "I never know. If they do the work they're supposed to do, yes (there can be success)."

"If she does the work it will be great. It's up to her how much of that she does, how much she feels she needs to do. It seems like she's doing rather well."

Three years later, she's dead.

Her body was found on the front porch of a home she shared with boyfriend David Wilson, who died in the same place - and fashion - 36 days earlier.

Pinsky issued a statement Sunday night after he learned of Mindy's demise.

"She is a lovely woman who will be missed by many," the statement said.

"Although I have not treated her for a few years, I had reached out to her upon hearing about the apparent suicide of her boyfriend and father of her younger (child)."

"She was devastated. Although she was fearful of stigma and ridicule she agreed with me that she needed to make her health and safety a priority."

"Unfortunately it seems that Mindy did not sustain her treatment."

What do you think? Does Celebrity Rehab actually help its cast members? Or does it do the opposite and actually make matters worse?

Tags: , ,
Avatar

It's sad when anyone takes their own life. I don't think alot of people who are on the outside looking in can grasp why? I hear many times all that money and fame, beauty wasted! They are human beings with problems like anyone else and along with all money,fame,beauty are a whole different set of problems. I don't think reality shows are to blame. They are sick and need help but only they can save their lives. A life vest can be thrown to them but unless they grab it and hold on for life so to speak. It won't save them they have to want it and apparently she had issues for a long period of time. I pray she is at peace in a better place where the worries and pain she was trying to get away from are no longer. God Bless her loved ones who are left behind and I pray her two sons will have lives of happiness and peace and will soon be back with family and not left in foster care.

Avatar

They sign up with Celebrity Rehab, they know they are putting their private lives out there. How could that make them worse? You decide and choose how you will live after treatment. If additional treatment is needed, then you go if you want to get well. Its your choice... No one is to blame!

Avatar

As always, you don't hear about the success stories, only the tradgedies. Dr. Drew is teaching them about addiction. He shows them what they need to stay sober, but he cannot be held responsible for people that do not follow their after care programs. Most of the people that go there are hard core addicts, they make the choice if they want to stay straight or use again. I think the show may very well help viewers that are addicted to see what they can do for help, or to see what happens if they continue to use. In no way is Celebrity Rehab responsible for the deaths of the ones that chose to use again!! My husband is a recovering alcoholic of twenty six years. He still is very active in his AA program. Many of the people he has seen come in the program over the years have gone back out. Some have died, but it certainly is not the fault of AA that they decided to go out and drink again. I think the program is amazing so that some people that thought they were too far gone can see what their options are..and that they CAN live a normal life again, IF they choose to follow the program.

Avatar

Ok, these people died from DRUGS AND ALCOHOL addiction. Although I don't necessarily agree with the show, Dr. Drew tried to help them. Heroin, meth, pills, and alcohol were the cause.

Avatar

Dr. Drew is not much better than Dr. ( sic) Phil and Oprah. They prey on vulnerable people by using them to advance their own careers and fame. Shame on them.

Avatar

Mindy MCready is an adult who died due to the poor choices she made. It is sad, but it is all on her.

Avatar

America is a failed society. Proof? The following story is the KKK Gypsys.

Mindy McCready Biography

A Mindy McCready Image Mindy McCready was a country singer who had success in the 1990s but spiraled out of control for years until her death in early 2013. It... More »
Born
Died
Birthplace
Fort Myers, Florida
Full Name
Malinda Gayle McCready
x Close Ad