THG Asks: Did Scotty McCreery Deserve to Win American Idol?

by at .
THG Asks!
Tags: , , ,

From Around the Web

    More From The Hollywood Gossip


    Nikko Smith: Mimi Faust Sex Tape Partner NOT the American Idol Nikko Smith

    Former American Idol finalist Nikko Smith is not the Nikko Smith who co-stars in the Mimi Faust sex tape ... just to clear that up.

    Malaya Watson Dubs American Idol Experience "Pretty Cool," Must Now Take ACTs

    Malaya Watson is headed home on American Idol. But she isn't too broken up about it.

    American Idol Results: Who Went Home?

    The American Idol results are in. So... who is now out?

    American Idol Performance Recap: 8 Sing the 80s

    American Idol took a trip to the 1980s this week. Was it a welcome flashback in time?

    28 Comments New Comment Subscribe


    Well, Scotty now has a song at the top of the charts. Guess you all were wrong about him. LOL. Stupid people!


    Scotty Mc Creery didnt deserve to win, the judges gave him a freepass to win. he only sang country songs. its not fair to the other contestants because they had to sings different kind of songs. he is not a bad singer but clearly got the advantages .


    Scotty was, is not, and will never be the right winner. I couldn't ever imagine me being happy about him winning unless all the top 25 was a bunch of Deandres (which will never happen, thankfully) he would never be a role model for me. He can't sing anything besides country


    Scotty didn't deserve to win it. Pia didn't either. I've heard many voices just like theirs. If they are saying Phillip is Dave Matthews, then Scotty should've been.500 bazillion country singers. Booooring. Haley should've taken the prize.


    4. hello there and thank you for your information e2€“ I have neeiditfly picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise a few technical issues using this web site, as I experienced to reload the web site lots of times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but slow loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and could damage your high quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I’m adding this RSS to my email and can look out for much more of your respective intriguing content. Ensure that you update this again soon..


    People just don't like TRUE talent anymore.
    Scotty is NOT a bad singer, but so many other contestants deserved it much more. All he sang was country, while others displayed various styles! He is good at country, nothing else.
    Also, all over the news were his fans saying how many times they voted for him in one night, which is not fair. When you vote for one person 30 times, on one computer in one's basically cheating. If it weren't for computer voting, I do believe he wouldn't have won. I'm hoping to see one person, one vote, per computer as a restriction next season.


    U guys are fooling yourself. Scottie'sfame will be well beyond your imagination. His fans love him so much and just can't get enough. This will continue for a long long time. His fans will make sure of it.


    Who the hell are you people! Giving Pia the lowest bar! Screw all of you!!! She is the best singer!!! So either all of you are a bunch of teeny boppers or a bunch of dumb stupid rednecks who don't know shit about music and talent!!!!!!


    Well done Scotty. You won because it was in the will of GOD. You are going to be a role model of good values to the youth. They are definitely being lured away by the music that they listen to. Stay blessed and remember that glorius that you have is a gift from GOD. Use it do glorify him.

    Leigh (15 years)
    South Africa


    james should have won rock on james

    You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register