THG Asks: Bachelorette Edition! Who Should Ashley Choose, Ben or J.P.?

by at . Comments
THG Asks!

Welcome to THG Asks, a feature in which two of our celebrity gossip experts debate topical issues in the entertainment world and you decide who wrote the winning argument!

Today, THG Asks: Who should Ashley Hebert choose on The Bachelorette season finale, Ben or J.P.?

BEN by Free Britney

He doesn't look like a stereotypical reality show hunk. Heck, he looks like a less handsome version of Constantine.

He uses phrases like "ruh-roh." He talks about his deceased father too much. He took his sweet time before he would truly open up to Ashley.

Frustrating? At times, yes. But all of these things are part of what make Ben Flajnik so human, so appealing, and the obvious choice for our girl.

There's no facade with Ben, a funny, smart, free-spirited Sonoma winemaker with a lot of heart (no matter how closely he guarded it for weeks).

He's the genuine article. Ben isn't fling material. He's husband material, a complex, nurturing guy with whom love can actually Evolve over time.

Hopefully, Ashley picks Ben and all he brings to the table on Monday's finale. If not, I bet come January, ABC can find 25 other girls who would.

Ashley Hebert and Ben Flajnik Date

Can Ben pull off the upset on Monday's finale?

J.P. by Hilton Hater

If I had a nickel for every time JP Rosenbaum and Ashley Hebert have made out on The Bachelorette this season, I'd have more money in my bank account than Chris Harrison gets for playing the most pimp-like host on TV.

These two have serious, lip-locking chemistry!

While others clearly came on for the wrong reasons (eat it, Bentley!), JP is as nice and honest as any contestant in recent memory. Has this made for especially entertaining TV? Not every week. But the show is about love, not ratings.

JP has all the physical attributes Ashley could want in a mate, as well. He's easy on the eyes and he resides in nearby NYC, just a quick car ride away. Might he be living a double life? Sure. But no guy is perfect.

THG Asks you ... who should Ashley choose?

 

Tags: , , , ,
Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip

Josh-andi-and-nick

The Bachelorette Season Finale Recap: Andi Dorfman ENGAGED to ...

It's all come down to this for Andi Dorfman, Nick Viall and Josh Murray. Come along as we recap The Bachelorette season finale LIVE!
Nick-viall-on-the-bachelorette-finale

The Bachelorette Spoilers: Are Nick Viall Videos a Giant Ruse?

Some of The Bachelorette spoilers apparently proving tonight's outcome have come into question. Here's why.
Shirtless-joe-manganiello

The Bachelorette Shirtless Showdown: Who's Hotter, Josh Murray or Nick Viall?

Josh Murray or Nick Viall: Which finalist on The Bachelorette looks hotter shirtless?
Marcus-grodd-photo

Marcus Grodd: Engaged to Lacy Faddoul!

In a match made in heaven, or at least in Bachelor in Paradise, Lacy Faddoul and Marcus Grodd have gotten engaged!

Avatar

Ashley Herbert is stunning and beautuful american women should come to australia melbourne . that what i think

Avatar

J.P. Is a hot head! I dont give them one year. She should have picked Ben, He is a true hearted person

Avatar

Its Monday nite and I just watched Ben talk more with, Ashley His love still shows. he'd take her back in a sec. I hope that the show, ask him to be the next Bachelor. He needs to move forward as soon as Ashley is married. or even sooner if he is sure wants to.. Intice him to try. He's has a strong constitution. I think he can do it. With what he said about his dad and wanting his own familey, he should! I know that feeling, I have been there it's not a good place.. Please try to get hin Hitched

Avatar

Its Monday nite and I just watched Ben talk more with, Ashley His love still shows. he'd take her back in a sec. I hope that the show, ask him to be the next Bachelor. He needs to move forward as soon as Ashley is married. or even sooner if he is sure wants to.. Intice him to try. He's has a strong constitution. I think he can do it. With what he said about his dad and wanting his own familey, he should! I know that feeling, I have been there it's not a good place.. Please ry to get hin Hitched

Avatar

Ashley's sister is a definite bitch that wanted attention drawn to her. What a bitch. She would be the last person that should give Ashley advise.

Avatar

I think either guy would be perfect. However, I also think she will pick JP who is a little old for her. She'll be happy either way.

Avatar

Double ditto on the Ben / Constantine comparison - Ben is better looking - not that it matters, because when you fall in love that person looks beautiful to you. Either guy would make an excellent husband for the right woman. JP seems far more into her at this point in time, and she into him. Of course we get the edited version of the whole story. But JP has seen her at her most vulnerable and some of her not so attractive points and he still was supportive of her. That says a lot about a guy and how he feels about you. Not only that, he is more likely to stay through the tougher times in a relationship.
Ben might too, but he is younger and has not had as many long term relationships, which gives JP the edge. Experience does help. Relationships are not always roses, romps on the beach, and fantasy suites.

Avatar

She should diffidently choose Ben. He is adorable and had taken so long to finally open up, but the fact that he has makes all the difference. By doing that I think hes WAY better than JP, who I think is kinda creepy.

Avatar

Ew Constantine is NOT good looking at all. Ben is the cute one between those two. I like Ben, but I think he is a bit young acting for her. JP all the way!

Terri-wright

I think either one would be good for her. oh and btw Ben is MUCH better looking then Constantine!