Skip to Content

The X Factor manufactured some drama around 19-year old contestant Tiah Tolliver last night.

After telling the judges she hopes to make it “platinum, double platinum and diamond,” this full-lipped hopeful broke into a cover of “Impossible.” Simon loved it. He said he had a “real feeling” about Tolliver.

But the other panelists didn’t agree, causing Cowell to label them as “insane” and leading to another cover by Tiah. This time, of course, she received approval and acceptance into the next round. Was this supposed debate drummed up ahead of time? Of course. But that doesn’t change the fact that Tiah Tolliver will be sticking around.

Does she deserve to be? You tell us…

Tiah Tolliver X Factor Audition