Skip to Content

Well?

Jacob, Haley, Casey, Stefano, Scotty, Paul, Lauren and James gave it their all tonight on American Idol. Who looked great out there and who’s in danger? You tell us.

If Pia Toscano’s elimination last week taught us anything, it’s that no one is safe. The critics, judges and conventional wisdom don’t decide. America will.

That said, tell us below who YOU think was the best tonight …

Who was the best tonight among American Idol’s top eight?