Skip to Content

Last night’s celebrity coach, Tony Bennett, has made 106 albums. In other words: these American Idol contestants have a looooong way to go.

But they all treated viewers to solid performances last night, as none of the renditions could be considered bombs. And, yes, that even includes Sanjaya Malakar. He was decked out in a white suit and sang as off-key as ever. Yet he didn’t make us wanna destroy our own eardrums for once.

Maddie Poppe Wins American Idol

The performer most criticized by the judges last night was Haley Scarnato. We’re not sure why. Then again, we may have been distracted by the beauty’s plunging neckline. She seems to be following the Alaina Alexander school of American Idolatry.

Not that there’s anything wrong with that.

On the non-Malakar male side, Blake Lewis shined again. He may not have the best vocal talent in the world, but this beat boxer adds a fresh spin to any song he performs.

But no one does that as much as Melinda Doolittle. She may be the best singer American Idol has ever seen. After all, no one has previously received the sort of compliment Simon Cowell dished out to this talent last night:

He can’t find anything to criticize her about. Wow.