Skip to Content

Following Monday night’s Bachelor finale and After the Final Rose special, we know this much about Matt James:

He is not dating Rachael Kirkconnell.

The former athlete sat across from fill-in host Emmanuel Acho yesteda and explained that, after selecting Kirkconnell to maybe be his future wife, he learned about the suitor’s questionable history of racially-insensitive behavior.

As a result?

Heather Martin and james

"Rachael might not understand what it means to be black in America," James said.

This was his way of confirming he had split from his Season 25 winner.

Matt even refused to embrace her toward the end of the aforementioned special.

Matt and Rachael on After the Final Rose

It’s safe to say there’s no future for these two as a couple.

Because Rachael can’t relate to Matt? Yes, in part.

But also because Matt may have moved on… already!

Matt James and Rachael Kirkconnell Together

A handful of astute observers have been studing social media activity out there.

These cyber-sleuths are convinced that James is dating Heather Martin.

Martin, of course, is a good friend of Hannah Brown’s.

Matt James is Sad

Heather even made a surprise appearance on this past season of The Bachelor.

ABC Entertainment Executive Rob Mills tried to claim at the time that Martin was insistent upon meeting Matt.

To hear him tell it, the network simply couldn’t turn her down.

Matt James Shirtless Photo

“She felt for sure this was her husband," Mills told cohost Julia Cunningham during the Tuesday, January 5 episode of “The Bachelor Recap” podcast.

"And," Mills continued, Heather "basically did anything she could to get there and track him down."

That is some aggressive phrasing, to be sure.

Photo via ABC

James entertained the notion of keeping Martin around.

But he then sent her home just a day after she touched down in Pennsylvania.

So… why are so many folks now convinced the two are getting it on?

Matt James GMA Pic

Reason #1: Despite barely making a dent on Season 25, Martin quaratined for the Women Tell All special, only to be cut from the broadcast.

If you recall, Kelley Flanagan was randomly shown in the crowd during Peter Weber’s Women Tell All special.

And then she ended up dating that Bachelor lead for awhile.

Matt James on the Finale

Reason #2: Both Heather and Matt have recently tagged Instagram posts San Clemente, California, even though James lives in New York City.

This is a small town. Why would both reality stars be there at the same time?

Unless, of course, they are there together.

Matt James In a Hoodie

Reason #3: Matt’s mother, Patty, was also spotted on Instagram of late.

Specifically, she was commenting in support of Heather’s clothing brand Titled Three.

"Love this and congratulations on making this happen. I love your #doitafraidmotto. So empowering," she wrote of the apparel.

Photo via Instagram

Is this all mere speculation?

Yes, of course.

But Weber ended up dating THREE different women from his season.

Matt James in the Woods
Photo via aBC

This sort of thing has certainly happened before. 

And we know that James is single and ready to settle down; he’s just waiting for the right person.

Kirkconnell was, well, not that person.

Matt James Toasts

As far as we can tell, Martin has never attended a plantation-themed party of any kind.

So she definitely has a shot here.

Stay tuned, folks.