Skip to Content

Now, it’s not every day that you see the words "Duggar" and "slutty" in the same sentence.

Which is probably why so many reality TV junkies were shook by a tweet describing Bachelor In Paradise star Caelynn Miller-Keyes as "the lost, slutty Duggar sister."

Caelynn and the Duggars

Now, if you’re a member of Bachelor Nation, you’re probably familiar with Caelyn from Colton’s season of The Bachelor, as well as the current season of Bachelor In Paradise.

We don’t think her behavior on either show could ever really be described as "slutty," but maybe it’s a relative thing.

After all, in the Duggars’ world, wearing a skirt that exposes your knees is considered downright scandalous.

("Knees are for prayin’, not displayin’" is something we could imagine Jim Bob saying.)

As first pointed out by Life & Style, the tweet that prompted a million surprised head nods reads thusly:

Take issue with the use of the word "slutty" if you want (We’re pretty sure it’s a joke, so maybe don’t take it too seriously?), but there’s no denying that the second part is true.

Once you see the resemblance between Caelynn and the Duggar girls, it really can’t be unseen.

And it seems the OG tweeter is not the only one who spotted the Duggar doppelganger among the swimwear enthusiasts on this summer’s BIP.

“Caelynn looks like she could be a Duggar sister,” tweeted one viewer.

Duggar Sisters: Counting On

“Is Caelynn a member of the Duggar family????!” added another. 

“I watched The Bachelor for the first time this season, and my takeaway is that Caelynn is actually Jessa Duggar wearing a ~very~ light disguise," a third remarked.

Yes, it’s widely agreed that the Duggar Caelynn most resembles is Jessa, who has been conspicuously absent from social media in recent weeks.

(This has yet to spark a rumor that Caelynn is actually Jessa in disguise, but the internet being the internet, we’re sure someone will put that out there eventually.)

Neither the Duggars nor Caelynn has spoken out about the comparison, which is of course not at all surprising.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes, Miss North Carolina 2018

After all, the Duggar girls probably aren’t allowed to watch shows like BIP.

This family is so sheltered, people were surprised when Jill took her kids to see Toy Story 4, as the Duggars typically steer clear of secular entertainment. 

Meanwhile, Caelynn is busy dealing with all that Blake Hortsmann drama.

In a way, she’s the anti-Duggar.

Jessa and company are always getting trolled for being evangelical prudes, while Caelynn is getting shamed for having sex.

Anyone for else see the makings for a killer podcast team here?