Impossible! Sacrilegious! Totally and utterly absurd!
Those were likely the reactions of many young X Factor viewers last night, after Nicole Scherzinger and Simon Cowell both told Drew Ryniewicz that they preferred her version of "Baby" to that of Justin Bieber.
Is the 14-year old really that talented? Listen to the original HERE, watch Ryniewicz in action below and then vote in our poll...
Whose version do you like best?