While choosing such a current hit is always a risk (especially a hit sung by, you know, Adele), Haley did her best to do it justice, vocally and emotionally.
Jennifer said there were moments where she did it better than Adele. We're not going that far, because it was far from perfect. But she held her own.
Watch Haley Reinhart do her thing here and vote below ...
Who do you think was the best on American Idol last night? Vote: