Skip to Content

We received such passionate responses the first time we pitted Vanessa Minnillo against Jessica Simpson that we wanted to give readers another chance to pick sides.

In the initial battle between these beauties, each vixen wore white. Thanks to Nick Lachey, of course, we know that’s not really appropriate anymore. Hence, the pairing of black (ugly) dresses below.

Jessica Simpson Is 4 Years Sober

Minnillo wore hers at a birthday party at Tao in Las Vegas last week, while Simpson opted for a floor-length gown at the Noche de Ninos Gala to Benefit Children’s Hospitals in Beverly Hills.

Who do you think wore her outfit better? And can Minnillo minions and Simpson supporters at least agree that each Lachey lover looks hotter than Anna Nicole Smith?