Sarah Michelle Gellar: Her Best Roles... RANKED!

by at .

She's been a vampire slayer, an evil twin and an advertising executive.

Throughout a career that began when she was only 16, Sarah Michelle Gellar has portrayed a variety of characters on television and on the big screen.

Which Sarah Michelle Gellar role has been our favorite? Prepare to disagree strongly, but we're counting them down below...

9. Kendall Hart, All My Children

Kendall Hart, All My Children
Sarah Michelle Gellar got her big break as a teenager on this beloved soap opera. She debuted in 1993.

8. Cici, Scream 2

Cici, Scream 2
Run, Sarah! RUN! We would have ranked this role higher if she had been in the original Scream instead.

7. Karen, The Grudge

Karen, The Grudge
Gellar just isn't right for a horror movie. She's too cute and too bubbly, too pretty and just too... normal. We hope she doesn't hold a grudge (sorry) against us for saying that.

6. Daphne, Scooby-Doo

Daphne, Scooby-Doo
It's hard to know how to judge this movie, considering it was meant to be a farce. Gellar wasn't exactly aiming for an Oscar. If you bought a ticket for Scooby-Doo, her portrayal of Daphne is all you could have asked for.

5. Bridget and Siobhan Kelley, Ringer

Bridget and Siobhan Kelley, Ringer
We're still not sure how this show didn't work. It seemed perfect for The CW, but it may have been too convoluted in the end.

4. Sydney Roberts, The Crazy Ones

Sydney Roberts, The Crazy Ones
Another show that should have worked. How did a sitcom with Robin Williams and Gellar go wrong? Was it too broad? Did it not have enough time to find an audience?

3. Helen Shivers, I Know What You Did Last Summer

Helen Shivers, I Know What You Did Last Summer
NO! This is not ranked too high! Go back and rewatch the classic movie with Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt leading an all-star cast and just try to claim it's not a blast.

2. Kathryn Merteuil, Cruel Intentions

Kathryn Merteuil, Cruel Intentions
A role so fun and juicy and iconic that Gellar will reprise it on a Cruel Intentions-inspired TV show in 2016-2017.

1. Buffy Summers, Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Buffy Summers, Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Come on. Did you expect something else at number-one?

Wait! There's more! Just click "Next" below:

Next
Show Comments
Star:
Sarah Michelle Gellar
Related Photos:
Sarah Michelle Gellar Slideshows
Related Post:
Created by:
Published: