Michael Strahan and Nicole Murphy ended their engagement recently, just as the New York Giants legend was set to be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Initial reports indicated that the split was amicable, and that the longtime couple blamed the breakup on their hectic work schedules on opposite sides of the U.S.
Then, the infidelity rumors started.
First, it seemed as though Strahan had been cheating on Murphy and the split was so poorly timed because she'd received "proof" that Strahan was carrying on an affair.
Just days before his Hall of Fame ceremony, Kelly Ripa's co-host was blindsided by the breakup story in what could not have been a coincidence.
Today however, the tables have been turned, as TMZ reports that Murphy was caught cheating with retired NBA player Jim Jackson.
The relationship between Murphy and Jackson was reportedly so serious that Strahan finally found out about it when the two decided to take a vacation together last month.
Sources close to Murphy say that she claims she was in Puerto Rico with her girlfriends, and just happened to run into Jackson who is an old friend of hers.
She's reportedly admitted that they hooked up, but claims that she and the man who was just enshrined in Canton were "on a break" at the time.
Murphy also continues to maintain that Michael cheated first.