Skip to Content

If you’re lost, American Idol viewers, you can look and you will find Colton Dixon. Time after time.

If you fall, music fans, Colton Dixon will catch you. He will be waiting. Time after time.

This season 11 hopeful went all Cyndi Lauper on viewers last night, covering the classic “Time After Time” and mostly receiving praise from the judges. Jennifer Lopez said she “really liked it,” while Dixon oddly enough admitted after the performance that he took his cues from a remake of the single by Quiet Drive, only changing up a couple notes here and there.

Where does Colton stack up compared to other remaining men, such as Joshua Ledet and Phillip Phillips? Judge for yourself now:

Colton Dixon -