Skip to Content

Jacob Lusk’s take on “Bridge Over Troubled” water on American Idol last night felt slightly off. Not full-on bad by any means, just … off. Do you agree?

Steven Tyler does not.

“How much of you you put into a song is phenomenal,” the judge said. “Those last three notes, and how well you fit in with the choir, is just incredible.”

“You’re such a gifted vocalist!” Jennifer Lopez, People’s Most Beautiful woman of 2011, added. “I didn’t want to let you give me the chills, but you did.”

Does it give you the chills?

Jacob Lusk - Bridge Over Troubled Water (American Idol)

Thoughts? Was Jacob’s performance enough to pull him through another week? Vote on who you think delivered the best performance last night here: