Melissa McCarthy Slammed as "Tractor-Sized Hippo" in Identity Theft Review

by at . Comments

Rex Reed of The New York Observer made his feelings very clear this week in an Identity Theft review: the critic is not a fan of the comedy.

That's perfectly reasonable, of course, but Reed is receiving major backlash at the moment due to his personal attack against actress Melissa McCarthy.

Melissa McCarthy in Identity Theft

In his critique, Reed refers to the star as a "female hippo," adding that she is "cacophonous" and tractor-sized."

"Melissa McCarthy (Bridesmaids) is a gimmick comedian who has devoted her short career to being obese and obnoxious with equal success," writes Reed. "Poor Jason Bateman. How did an actor so charming, talented, attractive and versatile get stuck in so much dreck?"

Ouch. Damn. Are these fair criticisms for a movie critic to make? You tell us: Referring to McCarthy's weight is...


Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip


15 Super Hot Stars Who Aren't Super Skinny: Their Curves Are Kickin'!!

Hollywood might say skinny is beautiful, but these women disagree! (And so do we!) Check out 15 super hot stars who aren't super skinny!

Melissa McCarthy Elle Cover Draws Ire, Magazine Defends Conservative Pose

Melissa McCarthy covers the new issue of Elle. But she doesn't show much skin on it.

Melissa McCarthy Responds to "Hippo" Comment, Pities Movie Critic

Melissa McCarthy has finally spoken out on the flap caused when a movie critic referred to her a "hippo." Read on for her mature take.

The Heat Movie Posters: Under Fire for Melissa McCarthy Photoshopping

Melissa McCarthy is clearly photoshopped in these posters for The Heat. Check them out now.


Her weight should have absolutely nothing to do with how good or bad the movie is. John Candy and Chris Farley weren't exactly beanpoles but they were hilarious.


what about a mobile "Pisten Bully"?