American Idol Elimination: Who Remains?

by at .

Despite having two chances to sing for the votes of viewers on Tuesday night, no American Idol finalist distinguished himself or herself this week.

Tags:

From Around the Web

    More From The Hollywood Gossip

    Mimi-faust-and-nikko-smith-picture

    Nikko Smith: Mimi Faust Sex Tape Partner NOT the American Idol Nikko Smith

    Former American Idol finalist Nikko Smith is not the Nikko Smith who co-stars in the Mimi Faust sex tape ... just to clear that up.
    Malaya-watson-says-goodbye

    Malaya Watson Dubs American Idol Experience "Pretty Cool," Must Now Take ACTs

    Malaya Watson is headed home on American Idol. But she isn't too broken up about it.
    The-great-8

    American Idol Results: Who Went Home?

    The American Idol results are in. So... who is now out?
    Caleb-johnson-faithfully

    American Idol Performance Recap: 8 Sing the 80s

    American Idol took a trip to the 1980s this week. Was it a welcome flashback in time?

    122 Comments New Comment Subscribe

    Avatar

    James should have won, no doubt!

    Avatar

    you guys made the wrong choice to let go.James is and was the best.He isn't finish we will be hearing from him in the future.

    Avatar

    OK, GAVE THE SHOW ANOTHER CHANCE AFTER PIA WAS ELIMINATED--NOW I AM DONE WITH IT. WHEN THE VOTING IS CHANGED I WILL BEGIN TO WATCH AGAIN.

    I WAS AS UPSET FOR JAMES AS I WAS FOR PIA.--HOW IN THE WORLD CAN HALEY, SUPER BITCH WITH LIMITED TALENT BE IN THE TOP 3!!!!

    Avatar

    James was the most versatile, multi talented performer Idol had this season.. it goes to show you that America ( or the voters ) are very unsafisticated and are really not in touch with music and raw talent.. too bad.. but he will make it. in spite of this.. his future is secure

    Avatar

    I truly hope we are not going to see the two showdown of the very young Country Singers. Haley you go girl!

    Avatar

    It is obvious who the producers want to have in the Finale... Hopefully the girl will be Haley... Gifted & Raw talent. The other two are so boring.

    Avatar

    Haley is a phenomenal singer, a throwback to a time when singing meant something. My hope is that she will someday do a Judy Garland song -- "Smile", for example. She has infectious charm, and that, more than her vocal power and range, is what speaks to my heart.

    The voting system at American Idol is ridiculously dysfunctional. More often than not, the poor singers are the ones who advance. So yes, it IS shocking when a brilliant singer with intelligence and artistic integrity reaches the final three.

    Avatar

    James is a good singer and proformer but metal has pretty well gone to the past as he said.
    The final run off will be Scotty and Laurn unless someone holds Laurn's age against her.

    Avatar

    I couldn't believe that James was kicked off. He should have won. America has officially pulled yet another "Daughtry" and sent the best home. But, like Chris, I have no doubt he'll still go far. He has way too much talent to let him slip back through the cracks of obscurity.

    Avatar

    I cant believe James is gone. James you can go far with your voice. Hopefuly Scotty can take it. The girls are not in to win it. Thats all I have to say.




    You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register