Skip to Content

Seven finalists. 14 performances.

On last night’s American Idol, the remaining contestants sang a pair of tracks each: first, they covered a “Now” single from the year 2000 and beyond. Then, they went with a soul-based “Then” song, tackling artists such as Marvin Gaye and Otis Redding. Relive the latter half of the evening below and then vote on your favorite…

Hollie Cavanagh for hour number-two started with “Son Of A Preacher Man,” one of our favorite singles from that era.

Hollie Cavanagh -

Up next, Colton Dixon went from Lady Gaga to Earth, Wine and Fire, sitting behind a piano for a version of “September.”

Hollie Cavanagh -

Elise Testone then got us into the mood via the Marvin Gaye classic “Let’s Get It On.” Will it help her move on?

Hollie Cavanagh -

Phillip Phillips proceeded to show off his versatility, following an Usher cover with a rendition of “Midnight Hour.”

Hollie Cavanagh -

From there, Jessica Sanchez made a plea to “Try A Little Tenderness,” as she hopes to avoid another placement in the bottom three. The judges, of course, are all out of saves.

Hollie Cavanagh -

Skylar Laine, who also did Lady Gaga proud with her first performance, then lamented how she “Heard It Through the Grapevine.” We adore her.

Hollie Cavanagh -

Finally, Joshua Ledet took us home by telling the world that “A Change is Gonna Come.”

Hollie Cavanagh -

Which of these performances did you like best?