Skip to Content

It’s not that Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald are bad singers, but their efforts have lagged behind the rest of the field at times on American Idol.

Did the twosome do enough to turn things around last night? Or are both in big trouble when the votes are tallied on tonight’s elimination episode?

Stefano elected to sing “When a Man Loves a Woman,” Percy Sledge-style, while Paul went on with Johnny Cash’s “Folsom Prison Blues.” Thoughts?

Watch their performances from Wednesday night below and tell us if you think either – or neither – should be receiving a ticket home this evening …

Stefano Langone - When A Man Loves A Woman (American Idol)
 
Stefano Langone - When A Man Loves A Woman (American Idol)