Skip to Content

Last week, we predicted that Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald would go home on American Idol, only to be stunned when Pia Toscano was eliminated.

This shows what we know, but we doubt we were the only ones surprised. Nor do we expect we’re alone saying Stefano and Paul may be in danger again.

Haley Reinhart also looked shaky, so it’s anyone’s guess. But neither Stefano or Paul took that step last night that would put them in the “safe” category.

Right? Wrong? Watch their performances here and comment below:

Paul McDonald - Old Time Rock And Roll (American Idol)
 
Paul McDonald - Old Time Rock And Roll (American Idol)