Skip to Content

Well? Who looked great and who’s in danger after American Idol tonight?

After seeing Jacob, Haley, Scotty, Lauren and James leave it all on the stage again this week, did the cream rise to the top? Who will make the final four?

Will Jacob make it through another week? Will Casey fans flock to Haley as he hopes? Can anyone stop James? Are the girls both dark horses? Talk to us.

We’ll post their performances on THG soon, but for now, leave a comment with your thoughts below and vote for who YOU think was the best on Idol:

Who was the best among the American Idol top five?