Skip to Content

Note to American Idol producers: 

You don’t need to keep churning out theme nights every week. It’s not, like a law or anything.

Following last week’s vague performance theme of Hits Since the Year 2010, viewers were treated to Rickey Minor and company playing a key role Wednesday evening for "I’m With the Band!" night.

It was random… but was it entertaining?

Yes, if you’re name was Alex Preston or Majesty Rose. These hopeful covered a couple classics and did No Dobut and Florence + The Machine, respectively, proud.

Who else stood out? Who will be on the chopping block tonight? Click through all nine performances here and then vote below:

WHO DID THE BEST JOB?