When two trusted sources of journalistic integrity - such as Life & Style and In Touch Weekly - publish contrasting stories, it's a bit like watching parents fight.
Whose side do you take? Who in this world can you trust? Where does the truth lie?
Such is our reaction today, as Kourtney tells Life & Style that she loves Scott Disick and really wants "to make it work."
"Everything between us is amazing," she said. "It's definitely been hard. But I just reached a point where I needed everyone to get over it. This is the father of my baby.
HOWEVER, this cover of In Touch Weekly paints a very different picture... literally!
In breaking, truly startling news, the tabloid states that Kourtney and Scott actually don't get along. They are - gasp!!! - faking their relationship for the camera. It also begs the question:
Is E! the "Devil?" We always thought that was Spencer Pratt, or the Smoke Monster from Lost, but we're open to it being any network that airs a show dedicated to the life of Bill and Giuliana Rancic.
You tell us: Has Kourtney made a deal with the devil?