Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald: On the American Idol Chopping Block?

by at . Comments

It's not that Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald are bad singers, but their efforts have lagged behind the rest of the field at times on American Idol.

Did the twosome do enough to turn things around last night? Or are both in big trouble when the votes are tallied on tonight's elimination episode?

Stefano elected to sing "When a Man Loves a Woman," Percy Sledge-style, while Paul went on with Johnny Cash's "Folsom Prison Blues." Thoughts?

Watch their performances from Wednesday night below and tell us if you think either - or neither - should be receiving a ticket home this evening ...


Emma, you are stupid!!!!! He is obviously my best friend's future husband, so back off crazy lady! I love you Stefano Langone>>>>from my friend... Leave him alone becuase they are like totally going out.


Say it ain't so !!


Stefano should stay -- Pia was good but she wasn't exciting. She never changed and you need to in this business.


i love stefano very much, i love his style of singing, his voice is very romantic and i vote for the grand champion of the American idol 2011


Stefano has an amazing voice and i dont see why people dont like him. hes my future husband...maybe.... but people need to stop hatin. vote for stefano everyone


Pia should not have been voted off. She signs great and will go far. Lauren can sing but she sounds like a baby when she is talking and acts like a child. Close my eye and she is okay. Open my eyes and ears and it's a different ballgame. Don't even get me started with Haley. Pia should still be there, the Lauren and Haley should be gone !


I agree 100% with you madrealacron, Paul is a true musician and an awesome one at that. I absolutely love him. He is overloaded with a thing called Charisma and it's something Pia very much so needed,but was lacking in that very important department.


Let's admit - Paul, Stefano, James - they can sing but quality wise? They don't have. The teeny boppers voted for them because of their looks. Jacob sings very, very good. I was guessing the competition would be between Pia and Jacob in the last round - if we are going to base this on singing competition and not looks. Haley has improved a lot. Anyway, I've seen on the web that a lot of people will no longer watch American Idol because of the mess.
I've lost interest also in watching. Bye bye.


Had a look at the site, Paul don't look at it.


votefortheworst site is claiming the only reason why Paul is still in is because of them, not a site to got to if you are a Paul fan, but worth a look. "geeks with power" :)

Tags: , ,

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]