People weren't sure HOW to react
That said, this example is unfair. The story of Tygrus is a beautiful tragedy, even if it was very awkward for Batman and even more so for a temporarily mutated Selina Kyle.
Some apologies are owed
The Cat in the Hat and Sonic have both gotten a lot of well-deserved flak, but Cats has outdone them both
This one is Too Real
This tweet is so right and it will haunt me to my core.
Yes, there are already reaction vids
No one can quite believe what they're seeing.
Who is emotionally prepared for this?
Cats is, after all, a famously not-very-good musical. Infamously so. Are ... are they making it ironically?
It made people yell at their screens
We've all had our moments of denial like this person did.