Did Shannon Magrane deserve to be sent home on American Idol?

Did Shannon Magrane deserve to be sent home on American Idol?

Shannon Magrane got the boot on Thursday, March 15. Did she deserve to go home on that date?
Added:
Will Shannon Magrane or Skylar Laine go farther on American Idol?

Will Shannon Magrane or Skylar Laine go farther on American Idol?

Decide now, American Idol fans: Which of these talented young women will advance the farthest on season 11 of American Idol?
Added:

Shannon Magrane Biography

Shannon Magrane Picture
Shannon Magrane is the daughter of a former Major League Baseball pitcher. The 16-year old advanced to Hollywood after an awkward... More »
Full Name
Shannon Magrane