Did Colton Dixon deserve to be eliminated?

Did Colton Dixon deserve to be eliminated?

Did Colton Dixon deserve to be sent home on American Idol at the point when he was?
Added:
Which American Idol put on the most soulful performance?

Which American Idol put on the most soulful performance?

The American Idol finalists sang a soul single for their second performance on the 4/18/12 episode. Which did you like best?
Added:
Which American Idol cover did you like the best from 2000 and beyond?

Which American Idol cover did you like the best from 2000 and beyond?

American Idol finalists performed songs from 2000 and beyond as part of their 4/18/12 performance show. Whose did you like best?
Added:
Were the judges right to save Jessica Sanchez?

Were the judges right to save Jessica Sanchez?

Were the judges right to save Jessica Sanchez?
Added:
Which show's cover of 'Somebody That I Used to Know' was best?

Which show's cover of 'Somebody That I Used to Know' was best?

Which cover of 'Somebody That I Used to Know' was best?
Added:
American Idol Top 7: Who Was Best?

American Idol Top 7: Who Was Best?

American Idol Top 7: Who Was Best?
Added:
Did DeAndre Brackensick deserve to get voted off American Idol?

Did DeAndre Brackensick deserve to get voted off American Idol?

Did DeAndre Brackensick deserve to get voted off American Idol?
Added:
Did Heejun Han deserve to be voted off American Idol?

Did Heejun Han deserve to be voted off American Idol?

Heejun Han got the boot from American Idol following his top 9 performance episode audition. Did he deserve it?
Added:
Did Erika Van Pelt deserve to go home on American Idol?

Did Erika Van Pelt deserve to go home on American Idol?

Did Erika Van Pelt deserve to go home on American Idol?
Added:
What did you think of Heejun Han's My Life performance?

What did you think of Heejun Han's My Life performance?

Steven Tyler took issue with Heejun Han clowning around during his performance of "My Life." What did you think of this American Idol...
Added:
Who is the season 11 American Idol favorite?

Who is the season 11 American Idol favorite?

Who do you think is the favorite on season 11 of American Idol?
Added:
Did Shannon Magrane deserve to be sent home on American Idol?

Did Shannon Magrane deserve to be sent home on American Idol?

Shannon Magrane got the boot on Thursday, March 15. Did she deserve to go home on that date?
Added:

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]