Skip to Content

Is ABC eyeing a possible return engagement (pun intended) for Emily Maynard on The Bachelorette? Maybe the third time’s the charm for the Southern Belle …

According to reports, producers want her to come back next season, just days after she confirmed her breakup with Jef Holm, her final rose recipient this year.

Who knows if this is legit or whether she’d have any interest, but that’s the rumor.

“Emily’s ratings were huge and the producers know she is incredibly popular so they are talking with her about coming back for another try,” a source teases.


“ABC loves Emily, there are tons of Emily fans and the producers think it’d be an amazing twist that would really get people watching, even if it is haters.”

“Even though she has been burned twice, they know it will be ratings gold and they know that she really likes being on TV and actually has fun on the show.”

Emily Maynard got engaged to Brad Womack on The Bachelor, but that relationship fizzled fast; things with Jef fell apart almost as quickly and she is single once again.

One of the men she rejected this summer, Sean Lowe, will dole out the roses as The Bachelor in January. Will Emily follow with her second Bachelorette stint in May?

What do you think: Should Emily be The Bachelorette again?