Melanie should be the winner. She is talented to sing just about anything. I am worried that her song choices should be more modern pop. Its up to the public now, so VOTE FOR MELANIE!!

Gooooo Melanie wow when she sings it touches your heart and thats what makes a good singer not only sounding good.

You got to give credit, when credit is due and she got good credit,i almost thought SIMON forgot talent when he hears yet....thaat girl can saang!!

Super talented and an amazing performance! Go, Mel!

She sang her heart out. That was the best performance so far. I recorded that episode and I watch her performance several times and it makes me cry everytime.:)