I will always be your number 1 fan. I can't wait for your album to come out! :)
rinikzen
May 15th, 2010 12:07 AM
SIOBHAN is the best here in the Phil.
Im sure theres a great future waiting for you!!
SIOBHAN IS MY AMERICAN IDOL
latelle kitzmiller
May 13th, 2010 4:46 PM
siobhan, someone will come along and invite you to open for them in the big arena, so never mindthe vote s by phone, or twit or whatever. My husband and I loved your stage presence, your voice, and the excitement that you exzude in your songs... I am not your teeny bopper fan. you can reach all ages of people with that special something, that elevates you above the rest... best wishes in your way up to the top..... we love yalatrelle and edward savannah georgia
Mark Joseph Villas
May 12th, 2010 4:24 AM
Siobhan is still no. 1 to my heart... and this is the beginning of her singing career! even you lost at the competition, your still the champion to me! not only mine also to all of your supporters... keep up the good work and and keep on singing, because i will buy all your albums in the near future!!! and i'll be your no.1 and greatest fan of all!!!
fenny
May 10th, 2010 8:09 AM
Siobhan is the best...
Audee
May 4th, 2010 6:00 AM
every little piece of her is right:) Siobhan rocks my world! i don't care if she lose on the competition. it's only the beginning! Siobhan will surely rocks the whole world just as how she rocks mine!!:)
Dr. C. Braunhardt
May 3rd, 2010 1:37 PM
From the very first time I heard you in the early trials, I knew you had THE voice and the looks! I never expected you to be "voted" off. Ignore people like Simon, who is obviously rude and arrogant -- and apparently has a tin ear!
Instead, understand this: You know how to work the cameras and the audience and you can be a huge success. Don't EVER give up. Your enormous audience wants to buy your first disc!
Mark Joseph Villas
May 3rd, 2010 9:32 AM
I'm from Philippines... again... i will be your no. 1 fan... we love you...
Mark Joseph Villas
May 3rd, 2010 2:05 AM
I'm so disappointed because you have been eliminated... last week.. and i'm so frustrated about it.. because i thought you will be the next american idol.. but even you have been eliminated, i still love you... and i will be always your no. 1 fan... all i wish for is someday we have meet... GOD BLESS!!! TAKE CARE ALWAYS!!! I lOVE YOU!!!
I'm sorry that you're not the next American idol, but I really love you, love your voice, your look. Just don't give up, go Siobhan!!!
DONALD GOLD
April 17th, 2010 12:21 PM
Siobahn, you go girl, you've got the voice and looks. you will make it. hang in there tough
MR
April 17th, 2010 3:02 AM
As the person below commented so PERFECTLY, I 100% agree with you!!!!! I could not have said it any better!! Simon see $$$$$ over Bowersox's head and is slamming Siobhan because she is a threat to his greedy agenda. He disgusts me...and Kara...seems to be getting into the act now too. perciray Says: April 6th, 2010 11:25 AM
jonmeldal
April 17th, 2010 12:18 AM
every performance of siobhan is right on. I've been looking at them over and over, all of them and looking and listning for different things. She always plays a role for the song but also sings with great power as if she's being pushed. Kinda reminds me of the old variety shows where the singer is a guest that is being payed to do a good job. Siobhan is a great student of the stage and has the amazing gift to belt it out and bring it down to tenderness. If you don't think her performances are well thought out down to the note or look, go back and watch all of them several times and focus on one aspect at a time.
francisdlcr
April 16th, 2010 3:57 PM
S......, you are such a very very talented singer we're with you all the way championship
Let the real competition begin TOP 7, I heard all the contestants sang week after week they all have the same weekly boring performances same song style same vocal range except maybe SIOBHAN, Forget about SImon COwell (SICO) hey..Siobhan U need to HIT that HIGH NOTE thats what makes u exciting & different from the rest don't let him bother you U R A natural talented singer.
After Adam Lamberts last song an AI.To have anyone compare themselves to his level of creativity is sad. I hope Siobhan sees this comment. I like you but anymore self promotion will do you in sweety. Watch out for your head getting too gigantic.
rubytuesday
April 14th, 2010 4:56 PM
SIOBHAN - Loved your performance and your reponse to Simon last night. My husband and I thought you picked the best ELVIS song -it was perfect for you. As others have posted, DON'T let Simon get into your head. Besides being super talented, lovely and possessing great stage presence, you are also determined to be yourself - FREE & REAL!! Ignore Simon and do what feels right to you.
debbie
April 14th, 2010 1:15 PM
Magnificent voice? NOT. Sorry, she has some talent, but it's not developed like Crystal, Casey, or Lee. Obviously you "fans" can't be objective and truely critique the singing on the show. And yes people she screams. Go back and look at the show where she said she taught herself how to hit those high notes by singing Kelly Clarkson in the shower. Well Siobhan it didn't work and frankly I'm surprised that Simon has been so nice about that screaming! Elvis night she finally sang well, no screaming and sounded very good. But she blew her opportunity to be unique and have a "moment" - Elvis would have been her time to "be different", like she claims she is. Instead she dressed conservatively and sang a caberet song. Sorry "fans" she shouldn't win Idol.
Misty
April 9th, 2010 12:54 AM
Siobhan is cute and quirky. She has a good voice, and I was glad that she toned it down this week. I was really getting tired of the screeching. I hear little children making the same screeching sounds.
i knw dat ur gonna win the american idol, just believe in urself coz i'll always be a fan of yours
SeanO
April 8th, 2010 4:20 AM
Ever Since I first saw her on American Idol, I totally fell in love with Siobhan. Haha. Everything about her is amazing. Her personality and her looks. I have to marry her! She's perfect.
carolb75
April 7th, 2010 3:46 PM
I agree that Siobhan should ignore Simon and be true to herself and sing whatever and however she wants to!
3K9s
April 7th, 2010 8:03 AM
Siobhan's voice and range is so superior to anyone on that stage that it is trully unfortunate that the judges have gotten into her head and will possibly ruin her career at age 19. Let the girl sing! Even the other contestants said her voice blows them all away. Let her sing Van Halen, Heart, Journey, anything that requires raw talent, loads of range. Anyone can sing one octave, but few can belt out with range. Don't kill the golden goose!
Siobhan~LOVER
April 6th, 2010 3:09 PM
Siobhan is soooo unique in her own way i love her i think her or crystal will win the boys SUCK!!!! well i love u siobhan....ill see u l8r on T.V CHANNEL 5... I WATCH AMERICAN IDOL ALL THE TIME I EVEN WENT TO AMERICANS IDOL 09 TOUR AT SPORTS ARENA AWESOME I GOT THEIR SIGNITURE AND A PIC......cool
perciray
April 6th, 2010 11:29 AM
No matter what SIMON will say against SIOBHAN he cannot changed the mind
of her solid fans the more he criticized SIOBHAN the more people will RALLY behind HER. We are seeing the resurgent of COOK v ARCHULETA, TIM URBAN OF SANJAYA These are the contestant that simon always dumped everyweek(xcept archuleta) to his dismay always comes back.
Simons favorite or CHOICE is always doomed to loose people just hate SIMON. CRYSTAL is SIMONs early CHOICE
perciray
April 6th, 2010 11:25 AM
Posted by E.B. 04—1-2010 at 09:03 AM. L.A. TIMES: This is highly recommendable for everybody to read ‘cuz its PERFECT.
An April Fool's Day story came out claiming Simon Cowell quit American Idol due to viewers ousting Didi Benami over Tim Urban.
Though truly the Urban myth, Lord Cowell should leave the show for having shown himself unworthy of even holding court at a Karoake singoff. The London Looney-Tune, it seems, has tainted himself as a bit of a bully, and thus, a coward. With his fear of a fellow troubadour being crowned American Idol 2010 instead of Crystal Bowersox, Cowbell has disqualified himself as a judge of any caliber with his attempts to cause Siobhan Magnus to cower before his monkey-minded comments. Cowell realizes Siobhan strides the stage as well as Crystal, but instead of encouraging the two artists-in-arms to wow us with their unique approaches to music, ol' Harry Chest has chosen to make Siobhan kowtow to his limpwristed opinions. Deriding the way
May 16th, 2010 10:30 PM
I will always be your number 1 fan. I can't wait for your album to come out! :)
May 15th, 2010 12:07 AM
SIOBHAN is the best here in the Phil.
Im sure theres a great future waiting for you!!
SIOBHAN IS MY AMERICAN IDOL
May 13th, 2010 4:46 PM
siobhan, someone will come along and invite you to open for them in the big arena, so never mindthe vote s by phone, or twit or whatever. My husband and I loved your stage presence, your voice, and the excitement that you exzude in your songs... I am not your teeny bopper fan. you can reach all ages of people with that special something, that elevates you above the rest... best wishes in your way up to the top..... we love yalatrelle and edward savannah georgia
May 12th, 2010 4:24 AM
Siobhan is still no. 1 to my heart... and this is the beginning of her singing career! even you lost at the competition, your still the champion to me! not only mine also to all of your supporters... keep up the good work and and keep on singing, because i will buy all your albums in the near future!!! and i'll be your no.1 and greatest fan of all!!!
May 10th, 2010 8:09 AM
Siobhan is the best...
May 4th, 2010 6:00 AM
every little piece of her is right:) Siobhan rocks my world! i don't care if she lose on the competition. it's only the beginning! Siobhan will surely rocks the whole world just as how she rocks mine!!:)
May 3rd, 2010 1:37 PM
From the very first time I heard you in the early trials, I knew you had THE voice and the looks! I never expected you to be "voted" off. Ignore people like Simon, who is obviously rude and arrogant -- and apparently has a tin ear!
Instead, understand this: You know how to work the cameras and the audience and you can be a huge success. Don't EVER give up. Your enormous audience wants to buy your first disc!
May 3rd, 2010 9:32 AM
I'm from Philippines... again... i will be your no. 1 fan... we love you...
May 3rd, 2010 2:05 AM
I'm so disappointed because you have been eliminated... last week.. and i'm so frustrated about it.. because i thought you will be the next american idol.. but even you have been eliminated, i still love you... and i will be always your no. 1 fan... all i wish for is someday we have meet... GOD BLESS!!! TAKE CARE ALWAYS!!! I lOVE YOU!!!
Rank: New User
May 2nd, 2010 9:46 PM
I'm sorry that you're not the next American idol, but I really love you, love your voice, your look. Just don't give up, go Siobhan!!!
April 17th, 2010 12:21 PM
Siobahn, you go girl, you've got the voice and looks. you will make it. hang in there tough
April 17th, 2010 3:02 AM
As the person below commented so PERFECTLY, I 100% agree with you!!!!! I could not have said it any better!! Simon see $$$$$ over Bowersox's head and is slamming Siobhan because she is a threat to his greedy agenda. He disgusts me...and Kara...seems to be getting into the act now too. perciray Says: April 6th, 2010 11:25 AM
April 17th, 2010 12:18 AM
every performance of siobhan is right on. I've been looking at them over and over, all of them and looking and listning for different things. She always plays a role for the song but also sings with great power as if she's being pushed. Kinda reminds me of the old variety shows where the singer is a guest that is being payed to do a good job. Siobhan is a great student of the stage and has the amazing gift to belt it out and bring it down to tenderness. If you don't think her performances are well thought out down to the note or look, go back and watch all of them several times and focus on one aspect at a time.
April 16th, 2010 3:57 PM
S......, you are such a very very talented singer we're with you all the way championship
Let the real competition begin TOP 7, I heard all the contestants sang week after week they all have the same weekly boring performances same song style same vocal range except maybe SIOBHAN, Forget about SImon COwell (SICO) hey..Siobhan U need to HIT that HIGH NOTE thats what makes u exciting & different from the rest don't let him bother you U R A natural talented singer.
Rank: New User
April 15th, 2010 1:12 PM
After Adam Lamberts last song an AI.To have anyone compare themselves to his level of creativity is sad. I hope Siobhan sees this comment. I like you but anymore self promotion will do you in sweety. Watch out for your head getting too gigantic.
April 14th, 2010 4:56 PM
SIOBHAN - Loved your performance and your reponse to Simon last night. My husband and I thought you picked the best ELVIS song -it was perfect for you. As others have posted, DON'T let Simon get into your head. Besides being super talented, lovely and possessing great stage presence, you are also determined to be yourself - FREE & REAL!! Ignore Simon and do what feels right to you.
April 14th, 2010 1:15 PM
Magnificent voice? NOT. Sorry, she has some talent, but it's not developed like Crystal, Casey, or Lee. Obviously you "fans" can't be objective and truely critique the singing on the show. And yes people she screams. Go back and look at the show where she said she taught herself how to hit those high notes by singing Kelly Clarkson in the shower. Well Siobhan it didn't work and frankly I'm surprised that Simon has been so nice about that screaming! Elvis night she finally sang well, no screaming and sounded very good. But she blew her opportunity to be unique and have a "moment" - Elvis would have been her time to "be different", like she claims she is. Instead she dressed conservatively and sang a caberet song. Sorry "fans" she shouldn't win Idol.
April 9th, 2010 12:54 AM
Siobhan is cute and quirky. She has a good voice, and I was glad that she toned it down this week. I was really getting tired of the screeching. I hear little children making the same screeching sounds.
Rank: New User
April 8th, 2010 7:26 AM
i knw dat ur gonna win the american idol, just believe in urself coz i'll always be a fan of yours
April 8th, 2010 4:20 AM
Ever Since I first saw her on American Idol, I totally fell in love with Siobhan. Haha. Everything about her is amazing. Her personality and her looks. I have to marry her! She's perfect.
April 7th, 2010 3:46 PM
I agree that Siobhan should ignore Simon and be true to herself and sing whatever and however she wants to!
April 7th, 2010 8:03 AM
Siobhan's voice and range is so superior to anyone on that stage that it is trully unfortunate that the judges have gotten into her head and will possibly ruin her career at age 19. Let the girl sing! Even the other contestants said her voice blows them all away. Let her sing Van Halen, Heart, Journey, anything that requires raw talent, loads of range. Anyone can sing one octave, but few can belt out with range. Don't kill the golden goose!
April 6th, 2010 3:09 PM
Siobhan is soooo unique in her own way i love her i think her or crystal will win the boys SUCK!!!! well i love u siobhan....ill see u l8r on T.V CHANNEL 5... I WATCH AMERICAN IDOL ALL THE TIME I EVEN WENT TO AMERICANS IDOL 09 TOUR AT SPORTS ARENA AWESOME I GOT THEIR SIGNITURE AND A PIC......cool
April 6th, 2010 11:29 AM
No matter what SIMON will say against SIOBHAN he cannot changed the mind
of her solid fans the more he criticized SIOBHAN the more people will RALLY behind HER. We are seeing the resurgent of COOK v ARCHULETA, TIM URBAN OF SANJAYA These are the contestant that simon always dumped everyweek(xcept archuleta) to his dismay always comes back.
Simons favorite or CHOICE is always doomed to loose people just hate SIMON. CRYSTAL is SIMONs early CHOICE
April 6th, 2010 11:25 AM
Posted by E.B. 04—1-2010 at 09:03 AM. L.A. TIMES: This is highly recommendable for everybody to read ‘cuz its PERFECT.
An April Fool's Day story came out claiming Simon Cowell quit American Idol due to viewers ousting Didi Benami over Tim Urban.
Though truly the Urban myth, Lord Cowell should leave the show for having shown himself unworthy of even holding court at a Karoake singoff. The London Looney-Tune, it seems, has tainted himself as a bit of a bully, and thus, a coward. With his fear of a fellow troubadour being crowned American Idol 2010 instead of Crystal Bowersox, Cowbell has disqualified himself as a judge of any caliber with his attempts to cause Siobhan Magnus to cower before his monkey-minded comments. Cowell realizes Siobhan strides the stage as well as Crystal, but instead of encouraging the two artists-in-arms to wow us with their unique approaches to music, ol' Harry Chest has chosen to make Siobhan kowtow to his limpwristed opinions. Deriding the way