Haley Reinhart's version of Carole King's "Beautiful" - a bit of a surprise choice from the singer - was good, but not great last night on American Idol.
But we can blame her background singers and ear monitor, neither of which did her any favors. Despite those hiccups, it was a cool arrangement.
Heck, to hear one observer tell it, it was beyond perfect: "Haley, you are as beautiful as all that song is," Steven Tyler says. "I just saw God."
Not hyperbolic at all, is he? In all seriousness, she was good:
Follow the jump to watch Haley's second performance of the night, a duet with Casey Abrams, and then vote on who you think was the best: