And the Winner is?

They own the country music scene, but whose music do you like better? Decide between Carrie and Taylor now!

Avatar

Definitely Carrie. I'm not into the princess-y, break up, puppy love story songs that Taylor writes/"sings". It's too immature for MY taste and age (funny, 'cause I'm the same age as her, but oh well..). I prefer Carrie's songs and her voice, they genuine and beautiful, just like her. :)

Avatar

This is exactly what CU says she doesn't like. Both Carrie and Taylor are very talented women. Some may like one over the other and that is their choice, which is what CU said. Country music has room for all different artists, styles etc. And here we are with a pole - Ridiculous! Why does the media/fans feel they need to pit one against the other. Do you see the same comparisons of say, Brad Paisly and Kenny Chesney, how about Blake Shelton and Keith Urban. No you don't, but yet the women are constantly put against each other. CU has great respect for TS as TS does for CU, so media/fans please let each of them be the artist they are and stop with the comparisons!

Avatar

ok first of all carrie does not like it when people compare her and taylor, because both of their music styles are different. comparing CU, and TS songs would be like comparing Jason Aldean song dirt road anthem, to don't you want to stay. (dirt road anthem is imo country music, meets rap music, and don't you want to stay is closer to country pop) for jason aldean it is the same artist, same genre of music, but at the same time one of the song i mention is closer to country rap, and the other song is closer to country pop, so comparing the two songs of which one is better is pointless, kinda like this poll. and fyi why in the world would carrie set up a poll where she is being compared to taylor, when she doesn't like people comparing her with taylor in the first place. CU songs are inspirational, dark, revenge, etc.etc, while TS songs softer, and more than likely was inspired by one of TS ex boyfriend.

Avatar

i really admire taylor for her song writing but thats all because we might as well make every pretty songwriter a pop star, Carrie def. blows her out of the water and sings about things that really matter

Avatar

Carrie Underwood news trick ( Use Taylor Swift's name to get news for Carrie ) set up a poll that Carrie is already ahead by a large margin before you put it up on the web for a real vote = News trick

Avatar

lol at some of the responses here
I prefer Carrie.Her voice/tone are much more pleasant to listen too( and she stays on key), and her songs are not just teenage relationship drivel.Her new cd is full of amazing songs on a variety of subjects.

Avatar

I'm sorry to Carrie Underwood fans but my vote goes to Taylor.
I find Carrie's songs so heavy and deep that i lose interest halfway through and switch off. Taylor tells a story in such a catchy way that it draws you in anyone can relate to it. Whilst Taylor doesnt have the strongest voice, hers is the most sincere as you can hear the pain and know the stories that go with it Also Listening to them both in interviews, Taylor has a natural sweetness and is very humble whereas when i listen to Carrie i just feel like I can't warm to her she isnt as open and genuine as Taylor. Taylor knows what it is like to be the fan who is captivated by their hero and she embraces the love and dedication her fans show her. She grateful for every hello she gets right through to every award, i just dont see that with Carrie

Avatar

Well, I LOVE Taylor's personality a LOT more than Carrie, BUT Carrie has a stronger voice than Taylor. They're both just as good in different ways. They're two different people with different musical messages, and different talents.
Taylor:
Amazing story telling in her albums
Pretty voice,
Amazing Live performances
Loves her fans to death Carrie:
Amazing strong voice,
Large vocal range
Amazing story telling in her albums (like Taylor)
Loves her fans to death Carrie isn't really good to compare to Tay, because her music is totally different. its aggressive and Tays is more storytelling.
So I can't vote, because I don't find it really fair :\ I'm so tired of people comparing each other and having to one-up someone... Can't we all like both?

Avatar

The question is ..."Who's Music Do You Like Better" You Swifty fans are not too swift!! It doesn't matter how long Carrie took to release her latest masterpiece.
Carrie has the voice of an angel and I prefer Carrie's music by a country mile!

Avatar

Taylor is much better.

Tags:
,
Related Polls:
Carrie Underwood Polls, Taylor Swift Polls
Related Post:
Created by:
Created at:

Carrie Underwood Biography

Carrie Underwood, Bangs Carrie Underwood, a native of Checotah, Oklahoma, rose to fame when she was named the winner of American Idol Season 4. Then Carrie... More »
Born
Birthplace
Checotah, Oklahoma
Full Name
Carrie Marie Underwood

Carrie Underwood Quotes

I feel more beautiful when I see the pictures after. I'm like, 'I wish I had felt like I looked like that when I was actually there.'

Carrie Underwood

I’m content with 90 percent of me. I like my teeth. Sometimes I wonder if my orthodontist realizes how important he was.

Carrie Underwood