The X Factor has named its first champion. Do you agree with America's decision?

Josh Krajcik, Melanie Amaro and Chris Rene
Avatar

josh i love u,umade me cry since day one.ur mom made me so excited i could'nt wait to hear u sing.and u should've won.i love u and god bless.enjoy ur ride

Avatar

OMG Melanie blew me away from the 1st tym she auditioned!!! This gal is a dynamite, y'all who thinks she s boring shud get a life! Fuck Beyonce give me Melanie Amaro anytime!!! I cant wait for her debut album um gonna be one of the 1st ppl 2 buy it. Simon has found a treasure in America and she is gonna go places! We in africa are crazy about her. She is amazing!!!

Avatar

WELL, I AM VERY SATISFIED WITH THE LAST SHOW OF THE YEAR, IT WAS SPECTACULAR, 2HRS WITH ALL THE TALENT, AND MELANIE WAS OVERALL THE BEST OF THE 3, MELANIE IS JUST STARTING OUT, JUST SIGNED HER DEAL AND WILL BE GIVEN ALL THE HELP SHE WILL NEED TO SUCCEED IN THE BUSINESS, THEY ARE SPENDING 5 MILL ON HER AND I KNOW SHE WILL ONLY SING SONGS THAT APPEAL TO HER, WHATEVER THEY COME UP WITH I AM SURE SHE WILL BE FANTASTIC, CAN'T WAIT FOR HER NEW SINGLE AND ALBUM, GO MELANIE GO, I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU, GOD BLESS.

Avatar

I liked Melanie, but feel there are so many vocalists out there that sing exactly the same, so for me it is just another of the same. Chris Rene, will do a lot better on the charts. He portrays a different voice tone, and has a great personality, which Melanie simply hasn't got. I also like Josh, is was awesome, better a selling voice. But for me Chris Rene will do the Best, and will have a great future. Go Chris.

Avatar

All I wanna say is that Melanie from the begginging should have won this. She was amazing every night I heard her. Her last performance made me cry. I think she deserves this 100%. GO Melanie!!!!!

Avatar

Melanie was the great talent find. Josh had great voice, but Chris was a no-talent guy who appealed only to other no-talents.

Avatar

It was my prediction all along that Melanie would win because of her singing talent. That's what really got her there. But does she have the X factor? I don't think so. Out of the three remaining contestants, I think Chris Rene had the X factor! Does he have the best voice? Absolutely not. But this was about that X factor, the factor that we can't quite describe or put our finger on, but we recognize it when we see it. It's that factor that continues to draw people to you. He has the drive, the winning and calm personality, the swag, etc., and I think people looked forward each week to what he was going to bring to the table. I certainly did. I wish him and all the other contestants well. I know that he and some of the rest have nothing to worry about as far as a future in the business (Astro, Rachel, Josh, etc), but $5 mil always helps. :o)

Avatar

Everyone who said Melanie doesn't deserve it sucks.First of all,Melanie WAS MORE CONSISTENT THAN ANY ONE ELSE SHE WAS THE BEST SINGER. JOSH WAS NOT AS GOOD AS A SINGER EVEN CHRIS SOUNDED BETTER THAN HIM. MELANIE ROCKS SO STOP HATING ON HER.

Avatar

It was rigged and there's no way the votes could have been accurate since all the phone lines were busy. Yes Melanie is an amazing singer but shes boring. She's no different than the singers that are already out there. And josh and Chris needed the money just as bad as she did. She said the most she's ever had is 200$...well she's only 18 or 19 so that's pretty normal. Josh is a very good singer also and atleast he's a little bit interesting but every time I saw Chris whether he sounded good or bad I was interested and always entertained!

Avatar

Are kidding me? Both Josh and especially Chris were inconsistent when it came to songs outside of their genre'. Melanie never wissed a beat, she was perfect every week. To say she'll fall flat is a joke! She and Rachael are the only ones that will be around for the long haul. I wouldn't buy albums of any of the others.

Tags:
, , ,
Related Polls:
Chris Rene Polls, Melanie Amaro Polls, Josh Krajcik Polls, The X Factor Polls
Related Posts:
Created by:
Created at:

Chris Rene Biography

Chris Rene Picture Chris Rene is a 28-year old from Santa Cruz. He advanced to the final 17 on the first season of The X Factor. “The advice I have... More »
Full Name
Chris Rene