Joshua Ledet tried, but could not make the American Idol final two. Did he deserve to go home?

American Idol Final 3
Avatar

No way that the finals of Idol should be based on the public's opinion. Because of it, you have the best contestant voted off! Joshua is hands down the best of all of them. He was undoubtedly the most amazing, even-balanced singer of the group. Every challenge he got he performed to the max, receiving rave reviews and comments from the judges. Jessica definitely is a close second, with a wonderful range in her voice. Clearly, "pretty boy" Phillip had the female crowd in his hands, and that of JLo's. But, for me, the true contest right from the start was with the double, JJo! Unlike these two, Phillip had a limited range in his 'slurring' voice and I believe he was lucky to have got so far in the contest. If he wins next week, well, I guess people deserve what they vote for.

Avatar

it WAS obvious last night that judges were pushing for Phillip seems really strange as he is another bland pretty 'white' boy (forgot what he sung after each night)Joshua was amazing -screams and all happy for Jessica at least.

Avatar

jessica and phillip bite joshua is the best.............

Avatar

I guess African American Males are not meant for Amercan Idol. We only had 1 make it into the semi finals since American Idol Started. Pull up all the winners and it will only be one Ruben Studard. Joshua is better than Seasoned Veterans.. The others are good but really in training...I bet you if you lined up every music star in every genre. They will say hands down JOSHUA LEDET. THIS SHOULD BE THE LAST SHOW.. THE VOICE HAS PAST IT UP IN RATINGS.

Avatar

ARE YOU SERIOUS? U.S. IS LOST WHEN IT COMES TO TALENT. JOSH IS 1000 TIMES THAT OF PHILIP, SO MUCH MORE TALENTED. IF JLO LEAVES BECAUSE OF THIS, I CERTAINLY DO NOT BLAME HER. OBVIOUSLY, THIS IS INSANE AND CRAZY. PLEASE, SIGN HIM ..NOT THE RAPPERS BUT THOSE WHO ARE READY FOR THE NEW R&B THAT BRINGS IT ALL BACK!

Avatar

Joshua is an amazing entertainer but his screaming really gets on my nerves after one song. I don't understand how Phillip made it this far and believe that he will never be a star. Jessica has one of the most beautiful voices that I have ever heard, but she isn't very creative. People are not going to pay the big money to hear someone copy other people's music. So, IMO, if anyone makes it big, it will be Joshua. He really is a huge talent and I will have to learn to not over sing every song.

Avatar

Way to go Philip! You will be the next American Idol and will have an amazing career because you are extremely talented and different than all the other "white guys with guitars!"

Avatar

Jennifer, Daughty, Joshua! -- this is the track recod of A. I. What a joke! I finally give up -- no more A I for me. The REAL American Idol just walked off the stage with his mother.
How sad!!!

Avatar

way to go phillip all joshua did was scream no real talent Phillip is definately the best voters got it right

Avatar

I'm watching from Canada. Joshua is the most talented idol ever. If you watch back on last night's episode it was as if they were all reading their teleprompters and instructed to give Phillip a standing ovation. Sadly, it is so evident it is fixed. And um how did Jimmy know to blame himself before the elimination. I guess American Idol producers think the general public is stupid.While Jessica and Phillip are talented, Joshua is a superstar. I predict he will be the biggest selling artist they have ever had. But I won't watch the finale,as a protest. Seriously, it's rigged.

Tags:
Related Polls:
American Idol Polls
Related Posts:
Created by:
Created at:

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]