Joshua Ledet tried, but could not make the American Idol final two. Did he deserve to go home?

American Idol Final 3
Avatar

Jessica is still maturing and she has a great voice, but still too
young she needs to have somebody tell her how to dress, much too old
for her age
Joshua was great, althought he needs to cut down the overkil and screaming. He was my vote, he will do well like all the others who did not win and made it big like Kelli Pinkler, Jennifer Hudson,
Adam Lambert and Clay Aiken. I pay to go see Phillip.

Avatar

Could not take Joshua's SCREAMING ANY LONGER...glad he's gone. AMEN...now only if that weirdo Phillips gets eliminated...ALL WILL BE WELL>>>>Jessica is by far the best singer in this competition...PERIOD>>>>IF THAT FREAK PHILLIPS WINS< I WILL NEVER WATCH THIS SHOW AGAIN>>...

Avatar

NO, PHILLIP IS NOT AN ORIGINAL, HE TRYS TO ACT JUST LIKE DAVE MATTHEWS. SO, NO ON THE ORIGINALITY!

Avatar

Phillip should have been voted off.I don't understand how people would think he is not great.iS IT BECAUSE HE IS BLACK. cOME ON GUYS GET REAL.

Avatar

Phillip deserves to win. He has a great voice & is original. Joshua would have made a great runner up. As far as Jessica is concerned I hope Phillip wins she deserves to be knocked down a couple of pegs. From the beginning the jusdes praised her and she thinks she's got it in the bag. She was voted of by the viewers once that should tell you something. But JLO made a spectacle of herself just to save another miniority that cant sing anything other than a ballad

Avatar

I believe that all three were the ones to go neck and neck, very thankful to see talent against talent. AND Jessica has been challenged more than Phillip and Joshua. Phillip actually (I checked wrong one) should have gone home. I have watched the judges expand on both Phillip/Joshua in the area of expertise and encouraged when they were not in their genre, by a little twist that men can do. Jessica has had to really grow and take on each challenge given by Jimmy and the Judges as they shape her in each of their expectations. BOTTOM line JESSICA not only deserves to win, she is American Idol. On a side note, American Idol's numbers wouldn't be as high as they are now.

Avatar

Jessica does have a impressive voice for sixteen, but still needs to mature some with it. While Josh, and Phillip produced week after week,were original in their own styles of voices. Every week I wanted to see what they were going to do. It should have been these two in the finale.

Avatar

I think all 3 finalists are very talented in their own way. However, I think Joshua is the best intertainer. Very surprised he was voted off but know he will be picked up and make us some good R & B.

Avatar

Joshua was not that great, let's all face it. Sure he sang "Mans World" pretty good, and yadda yadda yadda, but think about it- it sounded the exact same EVERY SINGLE WEEK. It became agonizing for me to watch him perform over the past few weeks... his repetitive high pitched yelping can get old very fast. His voice also is not marketable to todays public. Seriously, no little teeny-bopper girl is going to get on itunes and buy a gospel album by Joshua. Speaking of which, why am I even on this website, or wasting my time watching American Idol?...

Avatar

Jessica should of been voted off
Joshua is definitely the best and phillips is the most original

Tags:
Related Polls:
American Idol Polls
Related Posts:
Created by:
Created at:

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]