Amber Holcomb has been given the boot from American Idol. Did she deserve to go?

Amber Holcomb Portrait
Related Polls:
American Idol Polls
Related Post:
Created by:
Created at:

1 Comments New Comment Subscribe


I don't think this elimination was exreemtly shocking, but kind of shocking. In my opinion, I found Pia to be boring, she has a amazing voice but absolutley have no stage presence and performing qualities. To be the winner of American Idol, you can't be just a good singer, you need to be a good performer too. But I have to admit, her River Deep, Mountain High Performance is where she did step it up. It's a shame she got eliminated after that. She should of made at least top 4 or 5.

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register