Keely Shaye Smith
Gossip

Keely Shaye Smith turns 44 today.

But many readers are unlikely to wish her a happy birthday.

After all, few topics have created as much stir on The Hollywood Gossip as a Keeley Shaye Smith picture with a caption that simply said our staff admires Pierce Brosnan's wife "for remaining true to who she is." Hundreds of comments have been left in response to this seemingly harmless statement.

Do you think Smith is setting an unhealthy example with her weight? Or is society truly critical of individuals who are thin and those who are fat these days?

Take a look at a few more Keely Shaye Smith photos, including the aforementioned controversial image, and weigh in with your thoughts now:

Last year, we posted a photo of Keely Shaye Smith in a bikini. Regarding the full figure of Mrs. Pierce Brosnan, we simply wrote:

We admire Smith for remaining true to who she is!

That comment set off a firestorm across The Hollywood Gossip, as many readers agreed it was refreshing to see a celebrity that wasn't obsessed with losing weight; while others actually labeled Smith as a poor role model for being so unhealthy.

Now that Smith has been spotted in public again, alongside her husband during for the premiere of Mamma Mia!, we wonder if readers will pick up the debate again.

Where do you stand on the appearance of Keely Shaye Smith?