Katie Cassidy
Gossip

It's official. Melissa Rycroft is a major celebrity.

Sure, she starred on the highest-rated Bachelor finale in the show's history.

And, yes, we know she's currently a contestant on Dancing with the Stars.

But you aren't an A-lister until you've been featured on a THG Fashion Face-Off. Welcome to the club, Melissa.

Rycroft's opponent in this edition is Katie Cassidy, who will star in the upcoming remake of Melrose Place. Compare the looks below and then vote in our poll:

Who looks better in this dress?

Actress Katie Cassidy, the daughter of musician David Cassidy, was snared by police a few weeks ago for alleged underage boozing. Ho hum, right?

Well, the crazy part of the story is that Katie Cassidy tried to get out of her arrest by pretending to be someone else - actress Taylor Quinn Cole!

Katie Cassidy, star of CW's Supernatural and longtime pal of Lauren Conrad and girlfriend of Jesse McCartney, was arrested in Tucson, Ariz., when she was riding in a car that was pulled over for several moving violations.

According to the police report, cops noticed that Katie Cassidy reeked of alcohol and that her face was "expressionless," they asked for I.D.

Cassidy allegedly told officers her name was Taylor Quinn Cole (who has guest starred on Supernatural - and is not the Taylor Cole who starred on Laguna Beach, mind you) and that she was from Vancouver (Katie is from L.A.).

Lastly, and most humorously, Katie Cassidy told the police that she was 21, and that her birthday was April 29, 1984 - which would make her, you know, 23.

After cops pointed out her l'il math mistake, Katie admitted lying about her identity, explaining that she was "a Hollywood actress" and was "scared."

The arresting officer then called her mom, who asked "what could be done" to help Katie's cause. We suggest getting O.J. Simpson involved somethow.

Love is in the air for hot young stars Katie Cassidy and Jesse McCartney, both 20, who have been together and smitten with each other for awhile.

But now, there's a rumor that they're engaged - and it comes from a source close to Katie - her good friend, The Hills star, Lauren Conrad.

On a bulletin posted by LC on MySpace, Katie, Jesse and LC's pals Whitney Port and Audrina Patridge met Lauren for dinner. That was when, according to LC...

"Then he got down and asked her. It was so sweet! Everyone was clapping afterwards."

After dinner, the happy bunch made their way out to club Mood to celebrate - appropriately, the same club where just last year, a photo of an underage Jesse McCartney drinking beer surfaced, launching an investigation of Mood.

Good to see he's hanging out there again. So is this rumor for real? When a rep for the Nick Carter knock-off was asked for comment on the engagement rumors regarding McCartney and Cassidy, he replied simply, "No, not engaged."

Hmm. Maybe it was just wishful thinking on the part of Lauren Conrad, BFF of Katie?

We'll see. In any case, Heidi Montag and her new, fake boobs were nowhere to be seen.