American Idol named 17 of its 30 semifinalists on Wednesday night, promising to reveal the final batch the following day.
But we were lied to, people!
The Fox competition, whose talent level has been especially high so far this winter, pulled a twist at the end of Thursday's installment.
After making the dreams of 12 more hopefuls come true, Ryan Seacrest said the final vote would be left up to viewers at home.
So Neco Starr and Ben Briley are left to wonder and pray as fans take to the Internet to voice their opinion, with the results to be announced Tuesday.
Combining both nights this week, here's a look at the Top 29:
So... who should move on?