She fell during her monologue. Multiple times.
She pretended to try out for The Voice.
She failed as Vanna White and she mocked the Mike Rice scandal as Rutgers.
Indeed, Melissa McCarthy hosted Saturday Night Live for the second time this weekend, taking on a number of characters and making an early bid to be the next member of the Five-Timers Club.
But that may be just one website's opinion.
How did you think McCarthy fared? Grade her latest SNL stint now: