Storage Wars Lawsuit: Judge Limits Scope of David Hester Claims

by at .  Updated at . Comments

David Hester's lawsuit against A&E, claiming he was wrongfully terminated and that Storage Wars is rigged, has been somewhat limited by judge's ruling.

As such, A&E has drawn first blood in this legal battle.

Dave Hester Picture

L.A. Superior Court judge Michael Johnson tossed Hester's claim of unfair business practices, and stated that his wrongful termination claims must be more specific.

Hester is a professional buyer of abandoned storage lockers; Storage Wars shows him and other buyers competing for the contents of those lockers.

He is challenging the producer's allegedly unethical behavior in "salting" storage units, which he says runs in violation of the Communication Act of 1934.

David Hester says A&E engages in the banned practice of "influencing, prearranging, or predetermining outcomes" in "contests of knowledge, skill, or chance."

Another of Hester's claims was that A&E committed unfair business practices, by making it appear that he is less skillful than his competition.

In response, A&E brought an anti-SLAPP motion to this claim.

Johnson said the claim arises from constitutionally-protected activity and the burden thus shifts to Hester to demonstrate "probability of prevailing" before proceeding.

The judge says he can't make the case, noting that unfair competition only regulates business practices within the arena of commercial speech.

Hester's claim, Johnson claims, "arises entirely out of non-commercial conduct concerning the production and broadcast of an expressive work."

Hester's lawyer attempted to point out that some of the activity that is being objected to wasn't aired. For example, producers issued press releases.

The judge found the argument "not persuasive," saying there is a distinction between speech promoting commercial activities and speech within expressive work.

The judge also dismisses Hester's claim of wrongful termination of employment in violation of public policy, but allows Hester to revive the claim with more specificity.

Hester's other claims for breach of contract and breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing weren't addressed at the hearing this week.

A&E says Hester is trying "to convert a garden-variety breach of contract claim into a tabloid-worthy drama, in which Hester portrays himself as a crusading whistleblower."

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip

Princess-marks-mug-shot

Mom Leaves Kids in Car to Hook Up With Man Across Parking Lot, Gets Arrested

Princess Marks, 25, took her two kids out in the middle of the night for a parking lot hookup with a guy. Police saw them and she was arrested.
Andrej-pejic-undergoes-gender-transformation

Andrej Pejic Comes Out as Transgender Model

Andrej Pejic has come out as a transgender model. She explains the change here.
Florida-couple-arrested-for-having-sex-on-beach

Florida Couple Arrested for Having Sex on Public Beach

This Florida couple has been arrested for a good reason: they were having sex in front of a lot of people.
Joseph-carl-mug-shot

Florida Man Run Over By His Own Pickup Truck, Charged With DUI

A Florida man has been charged with DUI after being run over by his own pickup truck.

Avatar

If this had not been staged they would ave found him in the back of the facility beat up and unconscious. I would have been happy to volunteer. Always hated they way he felt he was better then everyone else and treated everyone like dirt. I stopped watching because of him. Will have to start watching again.

Avatar
@ Beth

lol....I think and agree totally w/you. However, so many people have such a grudge against him. I think it would be a very long line. We would only get to watch as EMS hauled him away. lol He is a total jerk always hated how he jacked up bids and would even put his locks on lockers before bidding was over....

Avatar

I HAVE ALWAYS HATED this guy, he's such a condasending A-HOLE!!!!!!!!!!!

Melissa-moncada

I HAVE ALWAYS HATED this guy, he's such a sleeze bag!!!!

Barbara-goff

What a Moron Dave Hester is, never did like him! Everyone know this stuff is fake and staged, hence the name reality tv, get over it Dave and move on!

Avatar

This man is an idiot...

Avatar

All Thom Beers shows are faked. Ice Road Truckers cast are pissed too.

Avatar

.....he is smelling money?

Avatar

sHOLEore loser . he was always a A