27 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

America got it RIGHT. Melanie should have gone home weeks ago! Amanda is talented, but she didn't step it up this week. While I don't think Nicholas will win, I enjoy watching him perform and glad he's in the finale.

Avatar

ugh the cassadee fans seem to be everywhere... voting like rabid dogs. Pretty sure they don't know what singing is supposed to sound like. (Don't get me wrong - Casadee can sing but she's medicore at best when compared to Amanda, Nicholas, Terry or Cody)

Avatar
@ Reshma

agree completely!

Avatar

Amanda got screwed. She was clearly the most naturally gifted vocalist. Terry will go nowhere. Let's be honest, he does what bands already did better 30 years ago. Trevin is boring and does the same thing each week. Honestly I fast forward half way through most of just performances

Avatar

America got it horribly wrong !
Melanie Martinez was screwed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

Avatar

Amanda got robbed.
Are people serious about Nicholas and Terry? Talk about 1-trick ponies.

Avatar
@ Big daddy

COMPLETELY AGREE! Nicholas and Terry horrible and boring and not modern at all, Amanda was amazing, and she could do so much.
Team Cassadee though

Avatar

I would love to see Terry of Lotus Crush ein, he's soo awesome, love his music!

Avatar

America got it right. Adam did not do a good job with Amanda and Melanie last night: He had both of them sing out of their usual genre, and this late in the game, America wants them to sing the songs that they would have on an album. Amanda has a great voice, but there was never a clear sense of who she was as an artist - rock vs R and B. I loved Melanie, but last night Adam had her sing that childish song that belonged on Sesame Street, rather than her usual unique folk singing. I put this on Adam rather than Melanie and Amanda - they sang the songs given as well as they could have.

Avatar
@ kcfield

Nah, Melanie sucked.

Avatar
@ acdcfield

Amanda and Cassadee both suck !
and so do you . ! you dont know Music!

Avatar

..........four singers aka magicians aka nurses?




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register