90 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

I am a HUGE Russel Crowe fan and have always been drawn in by his performances, but he absolutely butchered the role and his voice was SO distracting and SO bad I was embarrassed for him. For those that say his detractors just don't know a good baritone when we hear it is nonsense. Is this production of one of the most beloved stories of all time not supposed to appeal to a wide audience?

Avatar

I loved Les Mis, but unlike you I thought Russell Crowe was the best Javert of all He actually brought more depth to the conflict he was having and I finally understood his suicide He also brought out more emotion to Javert's character and made the conflict more understandable
Can't even believe your critic except maybe you just don't like Russell himself
He was magnificent as Javert They all left their hearts on the big screen As far as his voice goes he was perfect His deep voice was part of what characterized him He can hold more than a note and is quite a good musician Thought he had the best male voice
For anyone that reads this go seeds Mis It is the movie to see WOW. And Russell Crowe. Hugh Jackman & Anne Hathaway all deserve Oscar nominations Don't know which movie you watched
I do hate critics when they bash something amazing
By the way it's not Russell's first musical That's where he got his start in "The Rockey Horror Picture Show"
And funny that I understood more about the internal conflict of Javert's character and why he committed suicide after letting him go So be brought more. clarity than ever and therefore brought so much more than past.versions And I've seen all of them I don't get paid to criticize like you, but you critic of Russell Crowe is rubbish

Avatar

Absolutely disagree! From someone with experience in the industry (stage and film and tv), I was in awe of Russel's performance and his voice was absolutely captivating. The depth and strength, as well as the technique he used resulted in a beautiful baritone sound. A Hollywood Gossip site with no experience or knowledge on the industry or singing, should not be judging or criticising!

Avatar
@ Emma

Yes, you can tell the critic has no musical experience. I agree with your review. The portrayal of Javier was different, but interesting and powerful.

Avatar

I absolutely agree. Javert is such a strong character with such powerful songs and russel Crowe just looted through them. I kept thinking "this jerk is such a pansy!" Plus! You can HEAR the auto tune applied to his performance. I could just slap whoever decided he would be a good idea. Go for QUALITY, not a famous face. Ugh

Avatar

First of all, if you wanted a movie of the stage production, rent the DVD. This is BASED on the stage production and novel. Second, Jackman has Broadway musical experience. Anyone complaining about his singing has a tin ear. Crowe, while not having a typical musical voice, has done a stage musical and has sung for many years. The difficult thing with him singing is that the brain takes a while to accept the actor we know as a singer. He does an adequate job and does not ruin the production.

Again, this was never meant to mirror the great stage production. It never could. Just like Phantom could never mirror the stage version. Also, I think that there are preconceived notions and biases against Crowe - and they show in some of the reviews. I also think that there is some snobbery in that Wolverine is singing in this musical.

Additionally, I have read reviews criticizing the movie for lack of dialogue. This is not your grandparents musical of the 50s or 60s. Get over it already.

Avatar

I think Russell did an excellent job in Les Mis. He has a lovely ON KEY baritone voice and was a breath of fresh air in a sea of tenors. I found his performance to be extremely emotive.

Avatar

It’s interesting that you didn’t like Crowe’s performance in this movie. I have seen an overwhelming amount of positive reviews about his performance, and how he humanized Javert. A bunch of my DISH coworkers invited me to go see this movie tomorrow, but I think I’m going to wait on this one. I put it in my Blockbuster @Home queue that I have through my DISH account, so it will be mailed to me when it’s released on DVD. I love that I get unlimited in-store exchanges at the Blockbuster store, so I can just drop the movie off when I’m done with it.

Avatar

How does it make sense to suggest he's struggling to hit notes on screen when all of the music is dubbed?

Avatar
@ John

It's not. The thing about Les Mis is that none of the music was dubbed.

Avatar
@ agnodike

The singing was live...that's what made it even better!

Avatar

While true Russel Crowe would be be considered to have an AMAZING singing voice, he was on key, and was pleasant to listen to. Not to mention they filmed those main songs directly through the camera instead of dubbing them over like most musical cinemas. I honestly thought it gave the movie a raw feel. Let's be real: while musicals are a lot of time fantasies, this is supposed to be depicting a real time, real people. Not everyone has a perfect broadway voice, but they sing anyway. It added realism. Get over it. His performance was amazing, and I don't think his singing detracted from this cinematic accomplishment at all.

Avatar
@ Haleigh

wouldn't**

Avatar

Crowe didn't sing like Javert should? I thought he did a great job playing Javert, he humanized him. He's not meant to really be a villain in the true sense of the word, thats what makes his character so intriguing. Crowe played him as cold and distant, which is much more accurate to the actual book. And anyways, how much do you know how Javert should be played when you don't know its Fantine, not Fontine.

Jonathan-debusk
@ Robert Salek

That's kind of the point of Javert. Javert is a black and white man in a world of grey. To "humanize" Javert is to render his suicide odd and meaningless, since the realization that his black and white ethics do not fit into the world is supposed to be what breaks his spirit.




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register