Comments (130 Total)


You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register


Avatar
Reply
appy

I don't want to place blame on Carly, she was great. Leann had tweeted 2 days before and the day before that she was sick. That must have caused the to be off her game. She also had a problem with the stair in her entry. I'd still give it 8 out of 10. Leann needs to can her rep and social media people!

Avatar
Reply
Michelle

Carly Rose can definitely blame LeAnn Rimes, BUT she should blame the Xfactor producers for putting her on stage with that train wreck of a person. The public despises LeAnn Rimes and her Xfactor performance shows how far her talent has fallen along with her morals and integrity.

Avatar
Reply
AG

Carly rose duet was really bad. She just doesn't know how to sing with others. And the perpetual stinky face she makes doesn't help. I'm sure her stage mom was inconsolable.

Avatar
Reply
Keith

Carly Rose is a 50 million dollar deal! Carly is the winner and always was the winner.Tate is good but not great like Carly. There are already to many like Tate in country music. We need a new pop star like Carly Rose. Someone please step up and help her!

Avatar
Reply
Rodney
@Keith

I agree and may be it was rigged for her to lose, therefore not being bound by the x factor contract as she is worth millions more. American got this one wrong

Avatar
Reply
Hollywood

Leanne Rhimes spoiled Carly Rose Sonnenclars chances of winning XFactor...the family should sue Rhimes for her drunken performance, which made the duet appear flawed, thereby swinging votes to Stevens, who is an ordinary country singer, one which I wouldn't pay to ever see or hear.

Avatar
Reply
Baja
@Hollywood

Someone should sue YOU for your stupidity. Don't blame Leann because this girl wasn't good enough to win.

Avatar
Reply
Rodney
@Baja

Holly smokes Baja. You too have not looked at you tube. Her hits are off the charts compared to Tate and yes she deserved to win and she is a superstar.

Avatar
Reply
Carol
@Baja

Yes, Leann messed up everything. But, anyway, Carly is already a star.

Avatar
Reply
Austin
@Baja

Carly is more than "good enough." She's going to have such a successful career. She is 13 and is already up there with Mariah Carey, Celine dion, and any of the best singers. Get out of here with your bogus comments, your argument is invalid.

Avatar
Rodney
@Austin

To Apr....Wow!! That comment is just plain ignorant. She is only 13 and for your info look at you tube...21M hits and growing just from her audition. She is on par with all of the artists (songs that she performed) otherwise she would not have made it to the top and have literally awed the judges. After all non of them believed she was 13. I believe it is you who are delusional

Avatar
Apr
@Austin

Go have your ear check, go watch Celine Dion performance, it's 1000x better than this girl. Do not put her into that elite grp, it just make you sound delusional.