I am not a huge Nicki fan and can't really picture her being a good Idol judge. However I do think that Brad or Keith would be great judges. I have always thought that there should be a country singer judge because of how many country style contestants they have on there. It just seems like it would be more fare to have judges from different genres on the panel. Steven, Jennifer, and Randy was a good mix but I still think there should be a judge to represent the country singers as well. Just my opinion.

This is just a joke so don't over react, but I don't think Niki Minaj is fit to be on American Idol because she has so many different personalities. Think about it someone maybe suck but she might have her tone deaf personality on and she would be like I think you should go to Hollywood!!!!! Lol jk, but I like Niki Minaj I just don't think she's the right judge.

Isn't she the one who mocked TV "censoring" by giving the finger at the Super Bowl...kind of a loose cannon to be putting in prime time IMHO.

This is not a race issue. Remember Mariah is bi-racial. This is not a hate issue. This is an issue of having the credentials to become a judge. As much as some of you may like her, she doesn't have those credentials. Merely "selling" does not qualify her to judge talent. And by the way, to Michelle, you aren't getting paid either.

Who's Nicki Minaj??????????????