17 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

I never watch! Ryan Seacrust is just plain annoying.........

Avatar

These shows have become more about the judges than the talent. They're all just trying to outdo one another. It's a shame. The judges don't need to be celebs to be good. In fact I think the opposite. They've become a distraction. Get some judges that are in the music industry that actually mold and mentor new, young talent. It's gotten out of hand. Hiring MC is a huge mistake imo.

Avatar

MARIAH IS A GOOD CHOICE. AS FOR A BOOST IN RATING, SHE WILL NOT MAKE A DIFFER.THE REALITY SHOW IS OLD.REBA IS A GREAT NOMINEE.I NOMINATE DOLLY.

Avatar

MC has more crazy, delousional, and obsessed fans then Paula and JLo ever had! Otta make the audition shows very entertaining!

Avatar

I think it is a bit premature to consider Adam Lambert. He has only been away for a few years and could use more cred. The person I think would make the best judge, and has experience judging as well, is Clay Aiken. He has accumulated cred over the years by album, tours, TV, Celebrity Apprentice, judged a singing competition for David Foster and most recently a singing competition at Carnegie for the Distinguished Artists. He has a pitch perfect voice with a large range and would be excellent and fair in judging.

Avatar

Finally! Finally! An american idol judge with true talent. What were they thinking getting j.lo no talent non singing ass. I love mariah so much will be watching now. No one could get me to watch AI. Simon has competition. Is he kidding himself with britney spears? He is as desperate as oprah for ratings.

Avatar

Wish Randy would leave....Steven Tyler was great last year when the 2 let him get a word in edgewise......
Only way I will watch Idol is if they get Adam Lambert on there he knows his music and is such a great interviewer......




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register