It is called American Idol - not Americas best singer! So in my mind the whole package; song, presentation, performaance, charisma, and yes vocal ate taken in to account. In my humble opinion Joshua and Phillip deliver the total package more than the two girls.
The show needs some modern talent for guest appearances like Gotye and Kimbra singing Somebody I used to know. I'm tired of all these oldies but goodies people. Time for some fresh talent on the show.
I have finally figured out that the people watching Idol are really voting for the best performer!!!! In my opinion, Phillip should have been the cast off.....I can't understand how in the world the judges can give all those great compliments to someone that screams when they are singing, and those can't seem to sing in tune. Go figure. I may not be so musically talented but I can tell who has a voice and who doesn't.....I think the judges need hearing aids.
Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.
Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]
Comments (39 Total)
Go Jessica Sanchez, you got soul, and your kinda cute ;-)
It is called American Idol - not Americas best singer! So in my mind the whole package; song, presentation, performaance, charisma, and yes vocal ate taken in to account. In my humble opinion Joshua and Phillip deliver the total package more than the two girls.
The show needs some modern talent for guest appearances like Gotye and Kimbra singing Somebody I used to know. I'm tired of all these oldies but goodies people. Time for some fresh talent on the show.
I have finally figured out that the people watching Idol are really voting for the best performer!!!! In my opinion, Phillip should have been the cast off.....I can't understand how in the world the judges can give all those great compliments to someone that screams when they are singing, and those can't seem to sing in tune. Go figure. I may not be so musically talented but I can tell who has a voice and who doesn't.....I think the judges need hearing aids.