American Idol Results: Down to Five
by Hilton Hater at .Following a performance night that saw the remaining American Idol contestants cover both Queen and a song of their choice, six finalists awaited their fate this evening.
And after both Stefano Langone and Katy Perry took the stage, we were left with Elise Testone, Hollie Cavanagh and Skylar Laine in the bottom three. There's no way viewers were voting out Laine, right? Right?!?
Right.
Instead, Elise Testone heard her name called by Ryan Seacrest to conclude the episode. The soulful crooner bid farewell via "Whole Lotta Love," as J. Lo got up and danced and the crowd offered one final ovation.
What do you think? Did America get it right? Should Elise have been eliminated?
Related Stories
-
Nigel Lythgoe Confirms American Idol Departure, Exits "Great Ride" -
American Idol Producers: OUT!
-
Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj Confirm American Idol Departures
Comments (26 Total)
I wondered if this 3 judges of American Idol know how to distinguish the good song & bad song, because after the contestant sing their song, they always say, it was fantastic, amazing, good etc etc. they always say that those 3 juddges, I just hope Simon cowell will be back, although, Simon usually critise the past contestant. But the thing is, like what i've said this 3 judges, don't know how to distinguish a nice song from a not a good song or the performer rather, the keep on saying, amazing, good, fantastic, that was really good etc etc
Jessica Sanchez has really got the voice, charm and true talent from all the rest of the group. She deserves to be the winner of American Idol.
Personally, I think it will come down to Joshua and Skylar in the end and hopefully Skylar wins.... they are the best.. Holly has really shown a big improvement over the past 2 weeks.. Philip is great in his own way.
Why waste time voting, Jessica has been voted by the judges as American's Best Singer, 2012. Can't those for Hollie, Skylar, Joshua and Phillip see that? JLO and Randy reminded us again tonite that Jessica should not go home, reenforcing their previous predictions. Thank the fake reality show producers that this season of AI is coming to an end. Hopefully a better show will compete with AI time slot or AI gets more intelligent, non bias, judges and gets rid of the "Save." Good nite Chet!
Jessca and josh are my best