American Idol Results: Another Surprise?

by at . Comments

Following the most surprising American Idol vote of the season, the top seven gathered once again this week to learn which of them would be going home.

After two performances from each of the contestants on Wednesday - along with a song tonight by Kris Allen and a tribute to Dick Clark - it came down to a bottom three of Hollie Cavanagh, Elise Testone and, for the first time so far, Colton Dixon.

And the unlucky eliminate-ee?

American Idol Top 7


"I need to apologize. I wasn't myself last night and I get it," Dixon said with class and grace upon hearing the news.

What do you think, THGers? Did America get it right? Should Colton have been sent packing?


she is a very sweet girl. We're all hoping she wins!Betty- I hope she wins too! She rellay does have a great voice.gracies- I haven't heard Jessica but then, I only watch Elise and then turn it off. LOL You're right- some of them are quite talented!Jane- I don't watch Idol or the Voice but had to this time, for obvious reasons. LOL Michele- They're not my thing either. But, since DoodleBug knows this girl, we watch until she sings and then turn the channel. LOL


Elise is definitely the BEST. She has such a unique style and voice.
The judges want someone really young to win. Elise is 29 years old and that doesn't make the producers enough money. Is this show rigged or what?????????


I just gotta say one more thing. The reason i think that american idol is also an insult to the major artist who really had to work extremely hard to get in the music industry and local artist who are still trying to get there is because, it's not based on your talent, it's based on your personality and how much drama you can bring to the show to crank up the ratings, American Idol is a Singing reality show. So I can only imagine how much respect the american idol winners get from their fellow brothers and sisters under the same record label as them. I bet you someone like Lil Wayne or Ne-Yo would look at a Scotty McCreery and say "How'd you get in?" Scotty McCreery: "I'm the American Idol Champion" Ne-Yo and Lil Wayne: Oh Foreal? Hahahahahahahaha................. Oh ok, uh......... (DEAD AIR.......)welcome to Universal Music Group man....


That show is so damn fixed. I can't even watch that shit and i would advise anyone who wants to be a contestant on it, to not go. Think about it, if you did go on there and you just so happened to get really far in the show, but you don't win, what happens after that? You've told your whole life story and possibly embarrassed yourself all for nothing..... You get nothing out of it..... You go back to your once private life, and now everyone knows about it and you're still broke as hell... What was the point. Ok. Let's look at the other side of it, if you go far and win, You get a 1 Million Dollar recording contract from J Records, get a couple spins on the Radio, Release 1 Album, and nobody hears from you again. American Idol is a bunch of bullshit. I wouldn't even waste my time watching it. FUCK AMERICAN IDOL!!!!!!!!


Dear 'PeeDee' first, I congratulate you for the 'original' name. Very nice. Second, Jessica Sanchez does NOT copy other singers. She is origial and makes every song her own. She is very talented and better than Colton Dixon. And third, Skylar does not shout when she sings. Instead, she sounds like she is trying to swallow a hole live cow. Her accent just makes it worse.


Yes, the top 7 are exceptionally talented however anybody could be sent home just like colton but mind you he will be a star!


Colton didnt deserve to go. he may not have the best voice but he has its own way to make a song his. Unlike Jessica Sanchez, she just copies the singers, she doesnt originality. Skylar Laine always shouts when she sings.


I never get how Colton's go so far, I always felt his voice was the weakeast from the group, I never liked his singing, i never get it, and it is true, many are getting boring at this time...but ELISE TESTONE has definetely become my Idol.. She is really special!!! VOTE FOR ELISE!!


I believed that america made the right decision to eleminate Colton. Amongst the bottom three, Holly and ellese cannot be elimenated just yet as they are both still good for the competition. In fact Ellese should be in the top three. She is a dark horse and can pull through only if she pick the right song. Hollie is steady but should not make the top three. Jessica deserved to be in the top two together with either Jashua or Ellise and she should win the competitiopn if she sings the greatest love of all in the final. For Jashua to win he should sing God bless the child


colton should not have been voted off, i belive elise should have gone home but if colton makes a record he will do grwat, he's gona be a super star


American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]